Dan Shaughnessy defends Jeff Kent-only Hall of Fame ballot


Dan Shaughnessy has been covering MLB for the Boston Globe since 1981 and was voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2016 after winning the J.G. Taylor Spink award.

Over the past two years, he has raised a lot of eyebrows with his Hall of Fame ballot, as it has only featured former Giants second baseman Jeff Kent. Shaughnessy joined 95.7 The Game’s “Willard & Dibs” Wednesday to defend his logic. You can listen to the full interview below:

Podcast Episode
Willard & Dibs
Dan Shaughnessy joins Willard and Dibs
Listen Now
Now Playing
Now Playing

“In my view, you want to be dominant at your position at the time you played, and not be a cheater,” Shaughnessy said. “From what I can gather, he fits those criteria. He was an MVP while playing second base. We know he wasn’t great defensively. He was regularly in the top 10 on MVP votes, he’s, I think, first in home runs at that position, a lot of hundred RBI seasons.”

Throughout his 17-year career, Kent’s top seasons came with the Giants. He won the 2000 National League MVP over his teammate Barry Bonds, by slashing .334/.424/.596 with 33 homers and 125 RBI, finished in the top 10 of MVP voting four times and topped 100 RBI on five occasions.

Shaughnessy said he thinks Kent has a stronger case for Cooperstown than second basemen Bobby Doerr and Bill Mazeroski, who are already enshrined in the Hall of Fame.

“Those people aren’t from his time, but I think among second basemen, [Kent]’s up there,” Shaughnessy said. “I’m glad he’s on the ballot. Because people hate you if you send in a blank ballot. They hate you no matter what you do. My town, they hate me because I didn’t vote for David Ortiz and whatever. I’m just trying to be consistent. It’s a hard thing. By definition, the writers are all jackasses, I get it. But people need to like dial it down a little bit and stop with the emotion and loving these guys more than your own family. Your family, they love you back more than these guys do.”

Listen to Bay Area sports talk now on Audacy and shop the latest Giants team gear

Shaughnessy omitted two of this year’s most controversial choices – Bonds and Roger Clemens – who are appearing on their 10th and final writers’ ballot. However, the two former stars, whose reputations are tarnished by their association with performance-enhancing drugs, could be voted in to the Hall of Fame by other committees.

“I think if Barry and Roger just started on the ballot now, they’d have a way better chance than having started 10 years ago,” Shaughnessy said. “It’s going to get easier for them, the younger you are. Look, [Alex Rodriguez]’s going to get in on the writers’ vote at some point in my view. Each year, the crabby, old bastards like myself die off and go away and get replaced by younger guys.

"Young voters, I see a lot of interest in, ‘Here’s my favorite 10. I wish I could vote for more.’ I’ve never seen a ballot with 10 Hall of Famers on it. I thought the charge was – who are the Hall of Famers on this ballot. Not who your favorite 10. I just don’t understand the big-haul mentality. But that’s another story.”