Jameis Winston or J.J. McCarthy? The Giants have a massive quarterback decision looming, and Tiki Barber believes Winston deserves one more chance to prove himself against the Texans. But with McCarthy's mobility offering a completely different dimension to the offense, the debate gets heated over which quarterback gives the Giants their best chance to win.
Evan Roberts puts Tiki on the spot as Giants fans weigh in on McCarthy's wild comeback against the Saints. Tiki explains why the quarterback debate might be missing the Giants' biggest problem: a rushing attack that has completely fallen apart without Jaxson Dart. Plus, despite all the offensive struggles and uncertainty under center, the Giants somehow remain comfortably atop the NFC East!
