The Giants are winning games, but are they actually as good as their record suggests? Tiki Barber isn't convinced, pointing to an inconsistent running game, a defense still missing Dexter Lawrence's interior pressure, and a team relying too heavily on individual heroics. Evan Roberts questions whether the Giants are actually better off after trading Lawrence, while the guys debate whether the struggling Eagles could still steal the NFC East despite their offensive line turmoil.
Plus, Jaxson Dart's growing national celebrity sparks a debate about what makes a New York quarterback a star, and a caller floats a stunning Yankees managerial candidate to replace Aaron Boone. The brand-new Fan Answering Machine delivers hilarious messages, while Evan reveals his least-watched World Series and makes an embarrassing discovery about his Red Sox hatred!
