Phillies fans unhappy about another Dick Allen Hall of Fame snub

By , Audacy Sports

On Sunday night, four MLB greats learned that they'd officially be enshrined in the Baseball Hall of Fame via the Golden Days Era Committee, and all four are deserving choices.

Podcast Episode
High Hopes: A Phillies Podcast
Our Last Podcast Until April, Probably, and Corey Knebel is a Phil
Listen Now
Now Playing
Now Playing

Gil Hodges, a fearsome slugger at first base with eight All-Star nods and a great glove to boot. Jim Kaat, a near 300-game winner but perhaps known even more for his fielding prowess from the mound. Minnie Minoso, a consistent and versatile star whose career spanned not two, not three, but five decades. Tony Oliva, a hitting machine with reliable offensive production throughout his career in Minnesota.

And perhaps more deserving than any of them, at least according to certain metrics — including career WAR — is longtime Phillies star Dick Allen. But instead of joining his peers from the Golden Days Era, he's on the outside looking in once more.

Allen earned 11 votes from the 16-member Hall of Fame Board-appointed electorate, made up of prominent names including Joe Torre, Ozzie Smith and several others. 12 were needed for induction, and that's exactly the number that Hodges, Kaat and Oliva received. Minoso, meanwhile, earned 14 out of the 16 votes. No other player on the ballot, some of which were Roger Maris, Ken Boyer and Maury Wills, received even three votes.

But it's all the same: Allen's time has not yet come, and fans aren't happy about it.

Listen to Philadelphia sports talk now on Audacy and shop the latest Phillies team gear

Allen finished his career with 351 home runs, 1,119 RBI and a .292/.378/.534 slash line. His career OPS of .912 is higher than names like Mike Schmidt, Ken Griffey Jr., Willie McCovey, Willie Stargell and several other Hall of Fame greats. In 1972, he took home the MVP Award with the Chicago White Sox and registered a 199 adjusted OPS+, a stat in which he ranks at No. 23 all-time (via Stathead).

Rk Player OPS+ PA OPS
1Babe Ruth206106261.164
2Ted Williams19197921.116
3Oscar Charleston18439201.063
4Barry Bonds182126061.051
5Lou Gehrig17996651.080
6Turkey Stearnes17742811.034
7Mike Trout17656601.002
8Rogers Hornsby17594811.010
9Mickey Mantle1729910.977
10Mule Suttles17236511.028
11Dan Brouthers1717691.943
12Shoeless Joe Jackson1705697.940
13Ty Cobb16813103.944
14Mark McGwire1637660.982
15Jimmie Foxx16396771.038
16Pete Browning1635315.869
17Dave Orr1623411.867
18Stan Musial15912721.976
19Hank Greenberg15960981.017
20Johnny Mize1587372.959
21Tris Speaker15812020.928
22Frank Thomas15610075.974
23Dick Allen1567315.912
24Henry Aaron15513941.928
25Willie Mays15512545.940
Provided by View Stathead Tool Used
Generated 12/5/2021.

LISTEN on the Audacy App
Sign Up and Follow Audacy Sports
Facebook | Twitter | Instagram