When Craig Carton suggests his co-host Chris McMonigle should throw out the first pitch at Yankee Stadium, things take a hilarious turn! Craig claims the fame is going straight to Chris's head, leading to an impromptu studio acting challenge to see how a "normal person" would actually react to the offer. Watch the chaos unfold as the Hoff, the intern, and an entirely clueless Gallo get dragged into the mix, with Gallo completely falling for the prank!
Jun 25, 2026
