Chris McMonigle examines the Yankees' offensive slump and the specific struggles of Ryan McMahon and the bottom of the order on The Carton Show. He questions Aaron Boone's decision to keep Paul Goldschmidt on the bench during a shutout loss and looks at the impact of the high strikeout rate. They also pivot to a lighthearted debate over the musical catalogs of R.E.M. and The B-52's.
01:20 - Yankee Postseason Expectations
05:50 - Ryan McMahon Concerns
11:28 - Ryan Weathers Dominance
15:20 - Yankee Bench Depth
18:22 - Music Catalog Debates
25:36 - Offensive Strikeout Issues
31:45 - Potential Trade Targets
36:25 - Postseason Roster Strategy

Apr 09, 2026



