The Giants have a quarterback controversy after J.J. McCarthy nearly engineered a miraculous comeback against the Saints! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy deserves to start over Jameis Winston, with Tiki breaking down the good, the bad, and the ugly from McCarthy's wild fourth quarter. Is he really just a younger, more athletic version of Winston? And is Jameis one bad performance away from losing his job?
Meanwhile, Evan absolutely unloads on Cam Skattebo, calling him one of the most overrated athletes he's seen in years! After Skattebo played just six snaps, Tiki explains why his struggles go well beyond fumbling and why John Harbaugh is desperately searching for a running back to seize the starting job. Plus, stunning news about Jalen Hurts' season-ending blood clots, the Giants somehow maintaining control of the NFC East, and why the Jets deserve no sympathy after their loss to the Patriots.
Oct 19, 2026
