Yankees Need Judge in Right Field Against Tampa Bay

Aaron Judge’s potential return creates a complicated Yankees decision heading into the ALDS. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree Judge belongs in the lineup if he can play right field, but a DH-only role could force the Yankees to disrupt a lineup that just dominated Boston and potentially weaken their defense. They also rip Jason Benetti’s unnecessary Babe Ruth comparison during Sonny Gray’s playoff start and debate the crowded NBC broadcast booth. Then a caller sparks a Giants quarterback hypothetical: if Drake Maye’s struggles continue, would they trade Jaxson Dart for the former MVP runner-up? Tiki and Shaun Morash strongly reject the idea, arguing the Giants still need to discover just how high Dart’s ceiling can be.