From Elway to Brady, ranking the 10 greatest NFL quarterbacks of all time

10. John Elway

There are plenty of deserving names to get this list going — Roger Staubach, Frank Tarkenton, Warren Moon — but we start with John Elway. The Denver Broncos quarterback was a nine-time Pro Bowler and 1987 MVP and ranks 10th all time in career passing yards and 12th in career touchdowns.

For much of his career, Elway's legacy was marred by the fact he lost three Super Bowls, but he salvaged his legacy with two Super Bowls to ride off into the sunset on top and cement his spot in the top 10. He is also one of the most clutch quarterbacks in the game, having led the Broncos on 31 fourth-quarter comebacks and 40 game-winning drives in his career.

9. Steve Young

Steve Young may not rank as high as some other in the all-time categories, but his career did not really get going until he turned 30. Young won two MVPs and was a three-time All-Pro in a career in which he was only an NFL starter for nine seasons. Yet, in those seasons, he led the league in passing touchdowns four times and led the 49ers to a Super Bowl (after Young won two others behind Joe Montana) in which he set a Super Bowl record with six touchdown passes in the game.

Young was also a threat with his legs, rushing for 4,239 career yards and 43 touchdowns in addition to his 232 touchdown passes in 169 games.

8. Johnny Unitas

What QB list would be complete without a mention of Johnny Unitas? He may not have the gaudy numbers of the quarterbacks of today, but he was a trailblazer for the modern-day quarterback. In his first of three MVP seasons in 1959, Unitas led the league in passing yards (2,899), TDs (32) and completions (193).

Unitas, like Brady and Montana, was also synonymous with winning. He was a three-time NFL champion prior to the Super Bowl era and then added a Super Bowl to his resume leading the Colts over the Cowboys in Super Bowl V.

7. Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Rodgers' career is far from over, as evidenced by his MVP season in 2020 and perhaps his best statistical season of his career, finishing with 48 touchdowns and a 70.7 completion percentage. The Packers quarterback may be the best on this list on pure talent alone, being able to make throws on the run and big plays with his legs — with 3,271 rushing yards and 31 rushing touchdowns in addition to his 412 passing touchdowns, which has him seventh all time and should be fifth by the end of next season.

Rodgers has one Super Bowl under his belt but it feels as if he has underachieved by not having another. Should Rodgers hoist the Lombardi Trophy once more, it is easy to see him eventually move into the top-5 of all time, perhaps even higher.

6. Drew Brees

The New Orleans Saints quarterback retired following the 2020 season to complete one of the most impressive careers in NFL history. Brees finished his career as the all-time passing yards leader with 80,358 yards and second on the all-time passing touchdown leaders behind Tom Brady with 571. His 67.7 career completion percentage is also the best among all non-active quarterbacks.

He led the Saints on a memorable Super Bowl run in 2009 in which he was named Super Bowl MVP. While he never won a regular season MVP, he did lead the league in passing yards seven different times, including four seasons of 5,000 or more yards, and led the league in touchdown passes four times.

5. Dan Marino

Dan Marino may not have any Super Bowls to his name, but that should not deter him from ranking this high on the list. Marino was a quarterback ahead of his time. His 1984 MVP season is one of the best ever by a quarterback, throwing for 48 touchdowns and 5,084 — numbers that were unimaginable at the time and those records stood until 2004 and 2011, respectively. In fact, no one ever touched 5,000 yards in a season until Drew Brees did it in 2008.

Marino did reach the Super Bowl that year, falling to the 49ers, and is often the biggest drawback when ranking him among the all-time greats. But he never had the supporting cast to help him get back. He continued to have a remarkable career, ranking sixth on the all-time passing yards and touchdown leaderboard. Marino led the league in passing yards five times and touchdowns three and finished with a 147-93 career record.

4. Brett Favre

Brett Favre had one of the most fascinating careers of any quarterback in NFL history. His gunslinger reputation puts him at the top of the passes intercepted list with 336 but he also ranks fourth all time with 508 touchdowns and 71,838 passing yards. He led the Packers to a Super Bowl in 1996 and was the iron man of football, starting in 297 consecutive games — a streak that may never be broken — and the only player in NFL history to win three consecutive regular season MVP awards.

3. Joe Montana

There is one word to describe Joe Montana: winner. The Hall of Fame quarterback is tied with Terry Bradshaw for the second-most Super Bowl rings by a QB with four and went 4-0 in each of his appearances in the big game.

In his 15-year career that spanned with the 49ers and Chiefs, Montana had a 117-47 record and 16-7 record in the postseason — the second best winning percentage behind Brady. He is tied with Aaron Rodgers with 45 postseason touchdown passes, also good for second all time.

There is no denying that Montana embodies winning, a quality that separates the good from the great quarterbacks.

2. Peyton Manning

Some may argue Montana deserves this spot over Peyton Manning due to the Super Bowls, but Manning is simply the better quarterback. His five regular season MVPs are the most of any player in NFL history. He is third all time in career passing yards and touchdowns. He holds the record for most passing touchdowns in a single season with 55 and was the first to break Dan Marino's single-season record with 49 touchdowns in 2004.

While he may not match Montana in Super Bowls, he does have two, including a Super Bowl MVP, to make him one of the best quarterbacks to ever play the game.

1. Tom Brady

It is a no-brainer on Tom Brady takes the top spot on this list as the best quarterback ever. He is the most decorated NFL player of all time — winning seven Super Bowls, five Super Bowl MVPs and three regular season MVPs. While Brady's championship record has helped establish his GOAT status, his 581 touchdown passes are the most all time and he is sure to pass Drew Brees for most passing yards as he enters the 2021 season in second with 79,204 — trailing Brees by 1,154 yards.