Skip to content

Condition: Post with Page_List

Listen
Search
Please enter at least 3 characters.

Latest Stories

Americans are eating less of this Thanksgiving staple

Audacy News: Traveler trepidation is high heading into Thanksgiving travel season

Turkey might currently be considered the main event at Thanksgiving dinner, but that wasn’t necessarily always the case. One expert says the data shows turkey’s time as the holiday’s anchor might even be coming to and end.

Before we get to turkey’s recent decline in popularity, let’s go all the way back to the first Thanksgiving dinner. According to the Columbian School of Arts and Sciences at The George Washington University, that celebration was attended by pilgrims from Europe and around 90 men brought by Wampanoag chief Ousamequin who arrived at the pilgrim camp after hearing gunfire.

“The only eyewitness account mentions just two foods – venison and wildfowl – and doesn’t indicate what else was eaten or how the food was prepared or served,” said the Plimoth Patuxet Museums in Massachusetts. That fowl could have been ducks turkey or other poultry.

Troy Bickham, a professor of history at Texas A&M University explained in a 2022 article from The Conversation that the tradition of eating turkey on Thanksgiving actually has more to do with how Americans observed the holiday in the 1800s than what went down back in 1621. He said that the whole event went through a reinvention of sorts thanks to poet Sarah Hale of “Mary Had a Little Lamb” fame.

As the editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book, she promoted Thanksgiving has a holiday in part with many recipes featuring turkey. Though turkey is from the Americas, it had also become the favored main dish for Christmas in Britain by the mid-19th century. Author Charles Dickens, who made turkey part of Ebenezer Scrooge’s redemption in “A Christmas Carol”, was behind that development. In fact, the turkey dinner in “A Christmas Carol” inspired Hale as well, according to Bickham.

Turkeys have remained a central part of Thanksgiving lore. For example, Tom the Turkey is a staple balloon at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade, now celebrating its 100th year.

But times are a changing. In an article for The Conversation this week, Jay L. Zagorsky, a professor of business at Boston University who has a group of wild turkeys living in his backyard, noted that U.S. consumers have been drifting away from turkey since the late 1990s.

While more than $5 billion worth of the birds were sold in 2025, the average American consumed 13.2 pounds of turkey last year. That’s down from 17.7 pounds in 1995.

Zagorsky said the turn on turkey really came around 2008, during the Great Recession. He added that turkey production occasionally ticks upward a little – as has happened this year.

According to the American Farm Bureau Federation, the U.S. turkey industry seemed to be recovering, this year, with turkeys raised and production “increasing for the first time since recent disease-related losses reduced supplies.” It also noted stronger domestic consumption, growing exports and lower cold storage inventories. However, the federation also acknowledged that disease challenges turkey growers, as well as higher food costs.

Turkeys and chickens both feed on corn and soybeans, and turkeys consume a higher percentage of soybeans. As it happens, soybeans cost about twice as much as corn, Zagorsky noted.

He said that has kept chicken prices more reasonable over the past decades. According to the latest data, turkey feed costs are up almost 80%, without accounting for inflation, since 2000, while chicken feed costs have climbed only 60%. Chicken is also more popular with the public. Zagorsky said chicken consumption has steadily grown as turkey consumption declines.

“We’re eating almost eight times more chicken than turkey,” he said. Zagorsky also explained that turkeys weigh around 10 to 12 pounds compared to chickens that typically weigh around four pounds. A big bird might be ideal for feeding a big party of extended family members, but most households simply don’t need that much bird at once.

Whole Homemade Thanksgiving Turkey
Whole Homemade Thanksgiving Turkey with All the SidesGetty Images

Turkey has also acquired a bit of a reputation for being bland. In the words of Jake Peralta of “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” some people find that it “tastes like napkins.” This week, the team of the Chad Hartman show out of Audacy station WCCO News Talk in the Twin Cities even engaged in the turkey debate this week when they questioned whether soup should be added to the traditional Thanksgiving meal.

You might be wondering what people are enjoying on Thanksgiving if they have forsaken turkey. Bon Appetit’s list of Turkey alternatives this year includes chicken, leg of lamb, salmon, vegetarian enchiladas and more.