First it was an extraordinary circumstance, then a telecommunications error, then a copper wire upgrade that went awry, and finally a router malfunction: And all of these 'official' explanations for the full ground stop of all American flights on Friday have people searching elsewhere for the truth.
And scared about what officials aren't telling us.
In their most recent explanation, U.S. officials clarified that the ground stop was not influenced by the newly implemented $875 million, AI-powered air traffic management system, SMART, which was launched just days prior.
After a lot of online speculation, the FAA announced the two events are unrelated.
So, what is the AI system? SMART integrates approximately 200 data streams to enhance air traffic management by predicting congestion and suggesting alternative routes. Officials explained, “The AI does the math, the AI does the computation,” while human operators ultimately make the decisions.
For instance, In initial tests, SMART was touted for rerouting 180 flights around Washington, resulting in an average time savings of 10 minutes and a reduction of 80 gallons of fuel per flight.
Still, plenty of concerns have been raised regarding the development of SMART, particularly about the lack of input from frontline aviation staff and the risk of AI generating inaccurate safety-critical information.
The rollout of SMART occurred against the backdrop of a persistent shortage of air traffic controllers in the US, with experts asserting that no AI system can fully replace the essential role of human controllers in aviation safety. And many pointed out that it seemed like a heck of a coincidence it rolled out three days before the ground stop.
"In October, House Democrats asked the Government Accountability Office to audit SMART, warning that frontline aviation staff had little input into its development and limited training, and raising the risk that AI could hallucinate safety-critical information," this report says.
For its part, the FAA released this explanation: "The ground stop was issued out of an abundance of caution. Safety is, and will always remain, the FAA’s highest priority. We will never compromise the safety of the flying public. The system was made stable and air traffic resumed as of 8:15 p.m. that same day. Recovery to normal operations will be slow and steady. We ask for your patience as airlines work to get you to your destination."
Specifically, they blamed a router for the massive ground stop, only the second one since 9/11.
"The initial investigation indicates that two potential locations as the reason for the excessive data flooding the systems: a radar site in Amarillo, Texas and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas. L3 Harris, the FAA’s current network service provider, had been doing work at the El Dorado site, including deployment of a new router. When these inconsistencies in the data happened, L3 Harris blocked those two locations and the network stabilized. The broadcasting function was also disabled on all the new routers as a precaution.
"We worked as quickly as possible to identify, isolate and address the cause. Because the flying public’s safety is our top priority, we waited for a period of time to ensure the system was stable before we lifted the ground stop and allowed flights to resume. The system is stable, and operations are returning to normal. The FAA and L3Harris continue to investigate the root cause and ensure this doesn’t happen again.
Social media is flooded with skepticism about this explanation, especially since the FAA initially said the culprit was an 'extraordinary threat.'
In the later statement, the FAA clarified it was not a cyber attack or a result of the AI upgrade.
"Although the ground stop was lifted in four-and-a-half hours, the impact will continue to be felt in the form of congressional hearings into the crisis, finger-pointing over who or what was to blame, growing concerns about the safety of the nation’s air transportation network, and how and when it will be repaired—or replaced," Forbes reported.




