In a redo of the meetings that prompted a sunshine violations investigation, the St. Louis City Board of Police Commissioners approved a new contract for Chief of Police Robert Tracy.
The new contract is similar to the one controversially given at an emergency meeting last month, giving the Chief a raise of around $110,000 to an annual salary of $295,000. This time, the agreement is shorter, expiring in January of 2029. It also eliminates the $24,500 retirement contribution.
Still, Mayor Cara Spencer remains steadfast in her criticism of the deal, pointing to the Chief entering into a new three year contract with the City a year ago.
"I don't believe there was any need to renegotiate [the Chief's contract," in any way shape or form."
Spencer questioned the new salary given to Chief Tracy, which the City will solely undertake after his previous salary was boosted by the Police Foundation in his first three years, then the University of Missouri-St. Louis as apart of his deal to work there as an educator.
"When you look at some of the salaries of similar police chiefs, $295,000 falls outside the norm."
Spencer also seemed to question the legitimacy of whether Chief Tracy really had an offer to leave St. Louis for another department, which was his reason to come to the board asking for a raise.
"There was some discussion that there may be some offers forthcoming to the Chief, no offers materialized to my knowledge."
In a statement sent to media, Board President Chris Saracino said "As we have gone through this process, we have heard loud and clear from residents, taxpayers, and local stakeholders. It was important to get this process right..
Chief of Police Robert Tracy said in the same statement he appreciates the Board's confidence, adding "“Our officers and professional staff have worked tirelessly alongside residents and community partners to make this city safer. I’m proud of what we’ve accomplished together, and I’m focused on building on that progress in every neighborhood.”
Criticism of the deal also came from the Police Union, who slammed the Board for giving the Chief a new contract while civilian employees work without one.
"The St. Louis Police Officers’ Association is deeply disappointed that the Board of Police Commissioners has again prioritized a new contract for one individual already under contract, while civilian employees have worked without a contract since June 2025," said President of the St. Louis Police Officers Association Martin Garcia.
I asked if President Saracino, Chief Tracy or any other board member would be available to comment further. I’ve shared their response. Compare that with President Saracino’s statement on the 28th after their attorney resigned following criticism from the Governor: @kmoxnews https://t.co/4ZUyz3zN8l
— Sean Malone (@SMalone27) November 18, 2026
The initial meeting that approved this raise was criticized by Governor Mike Kehoe, who said numerous times the Board received "bad advice." It resulted in the Board's Attorney resigning and prompted an investigation into potential sunshine violations.
In the aftermath, Board President Chris Saracino said “our community deserves openness and transparency from this Board, and we fell short. We will do better." KMOX asked if Saracino, Tracy or any of the other board members would be made available for interviews to discuss the contract. A spokesperson for the department declined said "we will not be providing interviews."





