The Knicks delivered one of the wildest playoff comebacks Madison Square Garden has seen in years, storming back from a massive deficit against Cleveland and sending fans into disbelief. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the emotional roller coaster of Game 1, the atmosphere inside the Garden, and why this comeback instantly entered the conversation alongside some of the most unforgettable moments in New York sports history.
The guys debate whether Cavaliers coach Kenny Atkinson cost his team the game by refusing to call timeout during the Knicks’ late run, while also revisiting legendary collapses that still haunt New York fans. From comparisons to the DeSean Jackson game and the Tyrese Haliburton dagger to questions about coaching reputations and playoff pressure, the episode captures the chaos, joy, and anxiety surrounding a Knicks team now sitting just three wins away from the NBA Finals.
May 20, 2026
