Group Therapy: Jesus Lite

Our caller today is very devout, and even said our station isn't nearly religious enough for her taste! She even called us "Diet Jesus" (No worries, we get it.) But after falling for a new man, and realizing he's not nearly as religious as her, she was asking our advice for how to up his God game. Is it okay to push a religion on your significant other? Or should she just let things play out?