(WBBM NEWSRADIO) — The Geneva Historic Preservation Commission rejected a request to remove the landmark status from an 1843 blacksmith shop.
The property, located at 4 E. State St., was bought by the Shodeen Family Foundation, which also applied for demolition. During the commission’s most recent meeting Tuesday evening, Commissioner George Stazen noted the site has significantly deteriorated.
“It’s not, aesthetically, the most pleasing thing I’ve ever seen,” he said. “The condition of the structure, currently, is beyond — in my opinion — any restoration.”
Still, other commissioners argued demolition should be a last resort and that the Shodeen Family Foundation could explore other options. Commissioner Lisa McManus noted the property sits within a TIF district and said the City has available funds to help with restoration.
Commissioner Jewel Jensen echoed that sentiment.
“Based on the information and the testimonies provided, I am not convinced that the applicant has proven it to be a financial or economic hardship,” Jensen said. “I am not convinced the applicant has explored all other redevelopment options or investigated alternative funding sources.”
The Geneva Historic Preservation Commission voted unanimously to keep the blacksmith shop’s landmark status and avoid demolition.
The property owners could still appeal the vote to the City Council.
Related
Related
Listen to our new podcast Looped In: Chicago
Listen to WBBM Newsradio now on Audacy!
Sign up and follow WBBM Newsradio
Facebook | Twitter | Instagram