Skip to content

Condition: Post with Page_List

Listen
Search
Please enter at least 3 characters.

Latest Stories

PALM CARD: A question of trust

Chicago Mayoral Runoff Candidates Vallas And Johnson Receive New Endorsements

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - MARCH 07: Chicago mayoral candidate Brandon Johnson holds a press conference

Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images

Back before Johnny Carson became "Johnny Carson," the longtime host of NBC's "The Tonight Show" was a comedian best known for hosting a game show called "Who Do You Trust?" Based on the discourse around City Hall over the last week or so, the answer from a number of Chicago leaders might as well have been "no one."


Issues of trust have permeated the fractured relationship between Mayor Brandon Johnson and members of the City Council bloc known as the "Budget Accountability Coalition" for months, but those questions took center stage on November 13, when Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch resigned rather than stand behind what she considered to be misleading statements from the mayor's finance team about the Administration's 2027 budget ... specifically the percentage of revenue in the budget that is considered long-term or structural.

The mayor told Chicagoans in his budget address October 21, and reporters numerous times afterward, that the percentage of structural revenue was 76%. But five days later, Gabrysch told aldermen during budget hearings that the percentage was more like 56%, because the Johnson Administration was counting money derived from a $480 million loan taken in part to pay police department settlements.

"I knew the numbers were hard when I took the job. I left because I wouldn't present them as anything less," Gabrysch wrote in an op-ed for the Tribune days after her departure. And it appears the city updated its budget materials on the day of her testimony to explain the discrepancy, though the mayor continued to use the higher percentage in public remarks.

And his attempt this week with Chicago Comptroller and now acting CFO Michael Belsky to describe the difference as a "technical interpretation" did not apparently increase the trust level of analysts at S&P Global. Their "CreditWatch Negative" assessment was released hours after aldermen voted 45-5 to authorize the powerful and respected chair of the City Council Finance Committee to launch an outside review of all statements, emails, slide decks and other materials tied to the mayor's 2027 budget, and possibly all of his previous budgets.

"The intent here is to do a granular review around all of the messaging around our financial position," said Downtown Ald. Brendan Reilly, who talked about the measure after the first of two unprecedented back-to-back special City Council meetings. The Finance Committee chair, South side Ald. Pat Dowell, said Gabrysch's revelations led her to question other statements the mayor's team has made about the budget: "I'd like to get to the ... to the truth."

"I don't even really know why there's even a question around trust," Mayor Johnson said during an appearance with Belsky at City Hall in an attempt to project managerial stability in an administration that's also operating with an acting budget director and acting corporation counsel. The mayor pointed to development projects he's approved in wards of aldermen who oppose his agenda, including Ald. Dowell, as evidence of "our ability to work together and build trust to accomplish what is good for the people of Chicago."

"This is not a matter of trust," the mayor said in an apparent attempt to question the motives of aldermen behind the review. "This is a matter of whose interests are we serving." And as he often does, he continued that he was serving the interests of working people.

"Do the people of Chicago deserve an elected leader that they trust to carry out their hopes and aspirations?" he asked.

That question took on added resonance this week, as auditors started their review of the nominating petitions Mayor Johnson filed last month in his bid for a second term in February. Supporters of mayoral challenger Willie Wilson say their review shows the mayor filed fewer than 5,000 valid signatures, fewer than the 12,500 needed to get on the ballot and well under the 30,000-plus signatures the mayor's team claimed he filed.

Ultimately, it'll be up to Chicago taxpayers to decide whether these questions of trust will affect whose name they select on the mayoral ballot. And unlike Carson's "Carnac The Magnificent," predicting the impact of this week is harder than peering into a sealed envelope.