Judge lets Camp Mystic reopen but freezes flood site, preserving evidence

A Travis County judge on Wednesday allowed Camp Mystic to move forward with summer plans but ordered the owners to leave the flood-ravaged section of the Hunt, Texas, property completely untouched
A Travis County judge on Wednesday allowed Camp Mystic to move forward with summer plans but ordered the owners to leave the flood-ravaged section of the Hunt, Texas, property completely untouched Photo credit RONALDO SCHEMIDT/ Getty

A Travis County judge on Wednesday allowed Camp Mystic to move forward with summer plans but ordered the owners to leave the flood-ravaged section of the Hunt, Texas, property completely untouched - a split ruling that gave both sides reason to claim partial victory eight months after catastrophic flooding killed 27 people there on July 4, 2025.

Travis County District Court Judge Maya Guerra Gamble ruled that Camp Mystic cannot demolish, repair, or reconstruct the cabins where campers slept when the floodwaters struck, and that the camp cannot modify its grounds, office building, recreation hall, or commissary - all focal points in the wrongful death lawsuit filed by the parents of 8-year-old camper Cile Steward, whose body has still not been found.

The court order, which will be finalized in the coming days, does not block Camp Mystic from reopening its neighboring Cypress Lake camp site, where cabins did not flood, this summer. The judge asked attorneys to return with a map showing a clear boundary between the Guadalupe River portion where children died and the Cypress Lake portion the camp seeks to reopen.

The hearing drew a packed courtroom. At least 200 people attended, with Camp Mystic supporters wearing green shirts on one side and grieving families wearing buttons bearing the girls' smiling faces on the other.

The only witness to testify was Edward Eastland, son of camp owner Richard Eastland, who died in the flooding while trying to rescue campers. Edward testified that the camp had security cameras around the campus, but no one was monitoring the live feed in the middle of the night as the waters rose, and when he tried to pull it up around 3 a.m., he was unable to do so.

Camp attorney Mikal Watts said Mystic had already enrolled more than 800 girls for the summer with nearly $3 million in tuition at stake if the camp could not reopen at all.

Both sides found something to embrace in the outcome. Cile's mother, CiCi Steward, said the ruling was "incredibly vindicating" in preserving evidence needed to understand what happened. Camp attorney Watts also praised the decision, saying the judge "did the right thing" by agreeing the Guadalupe River evidence must be protected.

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick has separately asked Texas regulators not to renew Camp Mystic's operating license while deaths are being investigated, and legislative probes are expected to begin this spring. Families of several victims have sued the camp's operators, alleging officials failed to take necessary steps to protect campers as life-threatening floodwaters approached.

Featured Image Photo Credit: RONALDO SCHEMIDT/ Getty