BUFFALO, N.Y. (WBEN)......Passion-driven pleas from students, teachers, parents and community members ended serving as key swing factors that had a divided Buffalo Board of Education vote to scrap a controversial plan that would have seen as many as 10 of the city's public schools either close or merge.
"If anything, it feels like we got a stay of execution," said Mike Jeffers, a Riverside Academy teacher.
Riverside was one of the schools targeted for closure.
The board, Wednesday night, voted 5-3 with one abstention to scrap the school closing plan, even though the district is now facing a potential $90 million financial hole and looking at the very real possibility of either New York's Department of Education send in monitors to oversee the district's operations or the district being governed by a hard control board.
In addition to casting aside the school closing plan, the board vote also discarded a four-year financial turnaround plan whose centerpiece was reducing the number of schools and buildings within the district.
And, by holding off on any school closing decisions, the district could be 100% cash poor and run out of money by the end of 2027, warned James Barnes, district chief financial officer.
Closing the schools would have saved at least $17 million annually but resulted in 108 district employees including 73 teachers - losing their jobs.
"Without the four-year plan, you run the risk of further default," Barnes said.
However, Dr. Kathy Evans-Brown said she expects the school closing issue to be revived in early 2027.
"Doing nothing is a decision that carries consequences of its own," Evans-Brown said.
For more than two hours, the board heard pleas from students, parents, teachers and community members with virtually all asking for a delay or an outright "no" vote on the school closing issue
The board vote served as a snapshot of just how fractured the nine-member board is on the school closing issue - but even the staunchest supporters of delaying the closing issue agree the financial issues need to be addressed.
"The financial issues are real," said North District representative Roscoe Henderson III.
Voting against the school closing plan were:
* Board vice president Adrianna Zullich
* Park District's Erik Bohen
* Central District's Lewis "Muki" Hawkins
* West District's Talia Rodriguez
* At Large member Larry Scott
Voting for the plan:
* Dr. Evans-Brown, who represents the East District
* Board vice president Janita Everhart
* Henderson
Ferry District representative Stephon Wright abstained citng the need for more information.
"Any plan must put the children and families first and this plan was not doing it," Hawkins said. "It seemed like the plan was putting the parents first."
For now, the Buffalo Public Schools landscape will not change.
"I think everyone definitely needs more time," said Abdullah Al Haneof, a Leonardo daVinci High School junior.
Board votes puts off any school closing plans until early '27
Board votes puts off any school closing plans until early '27





