Minnesota civil rights activists are speaking out about a moment of silence held at the Republican party's endorsing convention for convicted former officer Derek Chauvin.
"You all have the opportunity to honor fallen soldiers or children who lost their lives at Annunciation," said Floyd's former partner Courtney Ross. "Instead, you took precious time to purposely hurt everyone who loved Floyd."
The mother of Philando Castile, Valerie Castile is demanding a formal apology from party leadership, calling the tribute a deeply traumatic act of disrespect. Castile was fatally shot during a traffic stop by police officer Jeronimo Yanez of the St. Anthony police department in 2016.
"We've all suffered tremendous loss on so many levels, and these are the people that we put in place to make our laws for the greater good," Castile said. "Now you take that opportunity and give a moment of silence to a murderer."
Community members say they're waiting to see how endorsed Republican gubernatorial candidate Kendall Qualls, and Minnesota House Speaker Lisa Demuth, who are both Black, will respond. So far, both have stopped short of being critical of the moment of silence for Chauvin, but did add it wasn't something they would have chosen to do.
"That was probably not the venue to do that or timing to do that," Qualls told WCCO's Chad Hartman on Monday. "I think there is a better way to convey that information. So, I think that's a good question. I got to tell you, given that some thought, I don't know if that was the venue to do it or the timing to do it."
"What I would say though is moments of silence typically have always been when I think of fallen officers and first responders," adds Demuth. "I think back just two years ago, to the Burnsville tragedy. I think just two years ago to Jamal Mitchell in Minneapolis. That is what I typically would think of at that time."
Minnesota GOP Party Chair Alex Plechash, on the WCCO Morning News with Vineeta Sawkar, said party leadership wasn't responsible, but refused to comment on it saying the court already had their say.
"I'm not going to challenge the court," he added. "So, I think I'll just let that pass."
Still, family members and members of the community want more contrition from Republicans.
“You all had the opportunity to honor fallen soldiers or children who lost their lives,” Ross, who was visibly emotional through “tears of outrage,” said Thursday. “Instead, you took precious time to purposefully hurt everyone who loved Floyd. And every other family who has lost a loved one to the police.”
What happened in Minnesota over the weekend
The Minnesota Republican Party nominating convention held a moment of silence last weekend for Chauvin.
When the action became public knowledge, it triggered intense backlash.
Racial justice groups, civil rights advocates and Democratic public officials swiftly condemned party officials, accusing them of blindly supporting law enforcement and disrespecting Floyd and his family.
Chauvin has been in federal prison since 2021, after he was convicted of murdering Floyd six years ago. Cellphone video of Chauvin putting his knee on Floyd's neck for over 9 minutes despite Floyd's pleas of “I can't breathe" sparked the numerous racial reckoning protests that dominated the latter half of 2020.
On the one-year anniversary of Floyd's death, people knelt in a moment of silence at the site, symbolizing the 9 minutes and 29 seconds Floyd was pinned down.
A delegate at the Minnesota GOP gathering in Duluth on Saturday proposed acknowledging Chauvin, according to reports from local news outlets. It occurred days after the sixth anniversary of Floyd's death.
“The moment of silent prayer was a spontaneous motion brought forward from the convention floor. It was not part of the official convention program, it was not proposed by Convention Chairman Danny Nadeau, and it was not a statement from party leadership,” the Minnesota Republican Party said in a statement.
A spokesperson for the Minnesota GOP did not immediately return an email Thursday seeking additional comment.
The impact of honoring a police officer — and not the person killed
Castile said it didn't matter if only one person participated, it was still hurtful.
“I am proud of the ones who did not do the moment of silence,” she said. “Those that did, they should be reprimanded in some fashion.”
Ross urged those Republicans who did not take part to hold their peers accountable.
“I’m speaking to the few of you that thought it was wrong. Please stand up," Ross said. “You are public servants.”
Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison, who led the state's prosecution of Chauvin, said in a statement this week he was “heartbroken and frankly shocked" by the prayer.
“This decision dishonors the memory of George Floyd and wounds his loved ones all over again. As the lead prosecutor whose team presented this case to a jury of twelve Minnesotans and then prevailed at every step of the appeals process, I am deeply troubled by what this says about the state of our politics," Ellison said.
Ben Crump and Antonio Romanucci, the attorneys who represented Floyd's family in a wrongful death lawsuit, were left “sickened by this lack of respect." They also demanded the Minnesota GOP retract their moment of silence and apologize to Floyd's family.
“The audacity of the Minnesota Republican Party to honor an individual who has both been convicted by a jury of his peers for the murder of a fellow human being, while at the same time (violating) a professional oath to protect and serve his community, is disgusting,” they said in a statement.
Reached via text message on Thursday, Floyd’s New York-based brother, Terrence Floyd, said he was “glad to see people are still fighting with us for complete justice.”
How some conservatives support police officers
The moment of silence for Chauvin fits a pattern of flashpoints when conservatives reacted to police violence with “back the blue” initiatives. Long before 2020, when George Floyd's murder catalyzed the largest racial justice demonstrations since the Civil Rights Movement, some officers were symbols of “law and order” or anti-Black Lives Matter sentiment.
For example in 2014, after Darren Wilson — the former Ferguson, Missouri, police officer who is white — fatally shot 18-year-old Michael Brown, who was Black, a GoFundMe website raised hundreds of thousands of dollars for the officer’s family and legal defense. The amount dwarfed the total raised for Brown’s family. Wilson ultimately did not face criminal charges or federal civil rights offenses.
Officers in the high-profile cases in which police killed Laquan McDonald in Chicago and Eric Garner in New York also drew sizable support from law enforcement unions that recast the criminal prosecution or discipline of officers as unjust and politically motivated.
Although legal outcomes vary a lot in these cases, most prominent examples of support for officers charged in killings do not result in overturned convictions.
Associated Press journalist Terry Tang contributed to this story.
The mother of Philando Castile is demanding a formal apology from Republican Party leadership
The mother of Philando Castile is demanding a formal apology from Republican Party leadership
