Skip to content

Condition: Post with Page_List

Listen
Search
Please enter at least 3 characters.

Latest Stories

Why the Patriots should pass on a Jimmy Garoppolo reunion

Los Angeles Rams v Los Angeles Chargers
INGLEWOOD, CALIFORNIA - AUGUST 17: Jimmy Garoppolo #11 of the Los Angeles Rams watches play against the Los Angeles Chargers in the second half of a preseason game at SoFi Stadium on August 17, 2024 in Inglewood, California.
Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

The Patriots face the death knell of most NFL seasons: an injury—potentially season-ending—to their star quarterback.



As Drake Maye undergoes further evaluations to determine the extent of the lower leg injury he suffered in Germany, New England has a few options for tackling the remainder of the season.

Will they waltz down a path of nostalgia and court 35-year-old free agent Jimmy Garoppolo?

Head coach Mike Vrabel said he didn’t foresee the team bringing in outside help at quarterback Monday afternoon.

“I don't see that being the case right now,” he said. “But we'll have conversations, and we'll discuss it, and we'll look and see. But Tommy and Behren Morton have been in our system, have been working. Behren Morton's been improving. He's been working each week, and I know that if he has to play for us, that he'll be ready to go. And I'm excited for this challenge, and I hope that everybody else is, because that's really where we're at. We're 5-5 in the middle of the season, just past the middle of the season, and we’ve got a bye, and we're looking forward to the challenge.”

Seconds after Vrabel concluded the press conference, NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported, “The Patriots are expected to explore the QB market during the bye week, from free agents such as Jimmy Garoppolo, who has previously played for OC Josh McDaniels, to potentially adding a QB off another team’s practice squad. Tommy DeVito is currently expected to become the starter.”

Garoppolo last played for McDaniels in Las Vegas, where he had a 3-3 record as a starter, a 65.1% completion rate, and a 77.7 passer rating. His last start came with the Los Angeles Rams in 2024. He played one game and lost, despite throwing for 334 yards and two touchdowns.

He spent three years in New England, where he started and won two games, before being traded to San Francisco. There, his once-promising career was waylaid by injuries.

That bad luck didn’t keep him from making a healthy $157.9 million over his career.

Which brings us to our first question: Why would Garoppolo come back? Is he itching to play again, but really so extremely picky that he would only play as a starter in this exact sort of situation, like Philip Rivers straight off the couch? How much would it cost to get him under center, and would the Krafts really want to pony up that cash for this experiment, only to pair a guy who hasn’t started in a couple of seasons with a team utterly decimated by injuries?

Furthermore, Garoppolo has seemingly been available since 2024. Teams like the Ravens and Vikings opted for other solutions in Jacoby Brissett and Kirk Cousins at the trade deadline. DeVito struggled against the league’s worst passing defense after missing live action from September to November. What would it look like for a guy who’s missed live action for the better part of the last two years?

Garoppolo would provide a fascinating narrative, but for the aforementioned reasons, it was a surprise to see his name tossed out there Monday. Even more surprising were the poll results garnered by WEEI, revealing that out of more than 2,000 voters, 56.6% want to see him back at the helm.

A decade has passed since Garoppolo’s lightning-in-a-bottle moment in Foxboro. Capturing it again is a pipe dream.