Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into two fascinating New York football what ifs, starting with Eli Manning’s newly detailed explanation for why he wanted no part of the Chargers before landing with the Giants. His story about a tense dinner with San Diego’s decision makers adds a fresh layer to one of the most important draft day sagas in NFL history.
The conversation then turns to Bill Belichick’s explanation for walking away from the Jets, including his concerns about the team’s ownership future and the alternate reality of James Dolan buying the franchise. The guys also touch on Mets and Yankees fallout from the Subway Series, Carlos Mendoza’s managing, Clay Holmes pitching through a broken leg, and what it all means for both teams moving forward.
May 18, 2026
