The Giants have a quarterback controversy after J.J. McCarthy nearly pulled off an unbelievable comeback against the Saints! With New York trailing 34-10 in the fourth quarter, McCarthy brought the Giants within one play of a stunning victory. But was his performance really as impressive as the numbers suggest? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy has earned the starting job over Jameis Winston.
Tiki goes throw by throw through McCarthy's roller-coaster performance, exposing several dangerous mistakes before a stretch of exceptional passing. Evan makes a surprising comparison, calling McCarthy a younger, more athletic version of Winston. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Giants' final offensive play and explains why Malik Nabers appearing wide open doesn't mean McCarthy missed an easy game-winning touchdown.
Oct 19, 2026
