Lawmakers weigh key bill that aims to protect veterans who experience VA medical malpractice

Photo credit Photo by John Steelman

One Marine veteran is working to protect 20 million veterans from the pain he experiences every day. 

Brian Tally has been working for years since he was irreparably injured by near-fatal Department of Veterans Affairs medical malpractice to ensure what happened to him does not happen to any other veterans. 

Two bills in Congress are named for Tally, and on Thursday, the House Veterans Affairs Committee for the first time brought one of those to a hearing. 

"We have come a very long way in our efforts in changing an outdated law that has dishonored veterans and their families for generations," Tally said. "We have fought for two years for a hearing. Our mission has been clear, consistent and positive from the very beginning, and that's protecting all veterans who seek treatment at all VA hospitals and clinics." 

The Brian Tally VA Employment Transparency Act would allow any veteran or family member who has filed a claim against VA for damage, injury or death to be entitled to receive, within 30 days, a notice from VA about legal council, the employment status of anyone involved in the claim (including whether they work for VA or are a contractor) and the statute of limitations for the claim.

"Brian has been a tireless advocate for veterans who sought care through VA and were harmed through negligence," Chairman Rep. Mark Takano, D-Calif. said during the hearing, adding that those veterans should have the right to know "who caused the harm and what legal remedies are available so they can be made whole." 

"It is unacceptable that any veteran be denied the right to pursue a claim because of a lack of transparency by VA," said Rep. Mike Levin, D-Calif., a sponsor of the bill. "Brian Tally has been a tireless and effective advocate for this cause." 

Levin asked VA officials during the Thursday hearing if there are policies in place at VA to communicate about their malpractice claims, including whether the medical professional was a contractor or VA staff before the statute of limitations expires.

Only one VA official present was able to answer the question at the hearing, but she could not be heard because of technical difficulties and was not physically present at the hearing.

"The answer is no and you know that," Levin said, in lieu of an answer. "It appears to be VA's position that it is acceptable for veterans to be denied legal recourse because VA did not provide them the information in a timely manner ... VA is unable to provide an unbiased opinion on what is in the veteran's best interest because it is in direct conflict with what is in the VA's best interest." 

VA's written testimony said it would be difficult for the department to keep track of claims and statutes of limitations for those malpractice claims.

"VA, a federal agency with a budget of over $200 billion," Levin said. "What makes you think it's easier for a veteran to keep track of this information, especially without legal counsel?"

VA officials were unable to provide any answers to Levin's questions during the hearing. 

‘If I waited, I would have died.’

Tally woke up one morning in 2016 with debilitating back pain that left him unable to stand or walk. Like many other veterans before him, he headed to the VA -- a decision that changed his life forever.

A doctor Tally said he thought worked directly for VA, but was actually an independent contractor, botched his diagnoses, delaying or denying critical care for months. His family was forced to pay out-of-pocket for private care that eventually prompted a battery of tests and surgeries to discover, and then fight, a bone-eating staph infection that was destroying his spine and threatening his life.

“If I waited, I would have died,” Tally says now, practiced in retelling his own brush with death and his family’s hardships.

VA officials admitted that Tally received second-rate care at the VA emergency room in Loma Linda, Calif., about 56 miles outside of Los Angeles, according to documents obtained by Connecting Vets. 

But a 73-year-old legal loophole allows VA to deflect responsibility for the malpractice, leaving Tally with no legal recourse, no way to seek recompense for losing his family car, his small business and putting him out of work for years.

VA deferred Tally’s federal tort claim, saying the VA employee responsible for the malpractice was a contractor and he had to file a state claim. Information they failed to pass along to Tally until it was too late and the statute of limitations in his state had expired, he said. 

“We nearly lost everything,” Tally told Connecting Vets while walking steadily from one Congressional office to the next to promote his bills. “My life changed in ways I never imagined or saw coming. I live and feel it every day.” 

But Tally has never given up. He knows what happened to him could happen to anyone -- with VA contractors nearly indistinguishable from normal VA employees, working “behind the VA veil,” he says. 

“I’ve been called to serve,” the former football and baseball coach said, grimacing slightly in pain but with a ready smile for the next Congressional staffer, Senator or anyone else walking the halls around him in one of his last trips to Washington, D.C. to promote the bills. “Hopefully this shows other people that one person can make a difference. If I can just help one person, it will be worth it.” 

The second bill in Congress named for Tally is the Brian Tally VA Medical Care and Liability Improvement Act which would ensure that VA health care contractors are subject to federal tort claims, to improve the accountability of VA physicians. 

Follow Tally’s efforts on Facebook at Rally Around Tally

One Marine is fighting to protect 20 million veterans from medical malpractice

Marine Brian Tally survived VA malpractice. Another bill named for him aims to protect his fellow vets.

Marine Brian Tally survived VA malpractice. A bill named for him aims to close 73-year loophole.

Other bills discussed by the committee included:

  • H.R. 6039, which would require VA to take over the Mare Island Naval Cemetery from the city of Vallejo, Calif.;
  • The Forgotten Vietnam Veterans Act, which would extend VA benefits to thousands of "forgotten" Vietnam veterans by changing the cutoff dates for the war to match the Pentagon's;
  • The Native American PACT Act, which would prohibit VA from collecting healthcare copays from a veteran who is also a member of a Native American tribe;
  • The Department of Veterans Affairs Tribal Advisory Committee Act, which would establish such a committee to advise VA on matters related to tribes and Native veterans;
  • H.R. 3582, which would expand the scope of the Advisory Committee on Minority Veterans to include LGBTQ veterans;
  • H.R. 96, which would require VA to furnish dental care to eligible veterans like any other medical care;
  • The Access to Contraception Expansion for Veterans Act, which would require VA to fill prescriptions for a year's supply of contraceptive pills or other forms of contraception;
  • The Honoring All Veterans Act, which would alter the VA motto to be more inclusive;
  • The VA FOIA Reform Act, which would require the department to reduce its backlog of Freedom of Information Act requests by 75 percent within three years and make frequently requested information publicly available;
  • The Veterans Economic Recovery Act, which would require VA to carry out a retraining assistance program for unemployed veterans;
  • The Accelerating Veterans Recovery Outdoors Act, which would require VA to establish a task force on the use of public lands to provide medical treatment and therapy to veterans;
  • H.R. 7287, which would clarify license requirements for contracted medical professionals to perform disability exams for VA;
  • The VA Mission Telehealth Clarification Act, which would allow health professional trainees to provide treatment via telemedicine;
  • The Protecting Moms Who Served Act, aimed at improving maternity care coordination provided by VA;
  • The Veterans Benefits Fairness and Transparency Act, which would require VA to publish its disability benefits questionnaire form in a central location on the VA website;
  • H.R. 7445, which would expand VA home loan eligibility to some members of the Reserve;
  • The Burial Equity for Guards and Reserves Act, which would extend VA burial benefits to those service members;
  • A draft bill that would extend certain employment and reemployment rights to certain activated National Guard members;
  • A draft bill to clarify the rights of service members and their employment and reemployment rights. 

Reach Abbie Bennett: or @AbbieRBennett.
Want to get more connected to the stories and resources Connecting Vets has to offer? Click here to sign up for our weekly newsletter.