LOS ANGELES (CNS) - Opponents of the state's outdoor dining ban aimed at slowing the spread of COVID-19 have filed a federal lawsuit, two weeks after a Superior Court judge overturned a similar order in L.A. County.
The lawsuit comes after restaurant operators were not able to resume outdoor dining despite the Dec, 6 ruling because the state's regional stay-at- home order contains an overriding ban.
A team of lawyers headed by Mark J. Geragos filed the complaint Sunday in U.S. District Court asking to block the state's outdoor dining ban on behalf of the owners of the Pineapple Hill Saloon & Grill in Sherman Oaks and owner Angela Marsden, according to the complaint.
The complaint alleges Gov. Gavin Newsom, Attorney General Xavier Becerra and Acting State Public Health Officer Erica S. Pan, M.D. "have seized the coronavirus pandemic to expand their authority by unprecedented lengths, depriving plaintiff and all other similarly situated small business owners in California of fundamental rights protected by the U.S. and California Constitutions."
The complaint specifies those rights are " freedom of assembly, due process, and equal protection rights under the First and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution."
The complaint notes the state has prevented the Pineapple Hill Saloon & Grill from serving food outdoors while allowing a major Hollywood production to serve meals to its employees and contractors inside an outdoor tent 20 feet away from the restaurant.
The complaint also claims the state continues to allow the entertainment industry, major retailers, grocery stores, marijuana dispensaries and other businesses to operate indoors and outdoors.
The complaint asks the court for an order " temporarily, preliminarily, and permanently enjoining and prohibiting defendants from enforcing the Regional Order" as well as Executive Orders and to order the state to pay attorneys' fees and costs.
{'byline': 'by City News Service', 'hosts': '', 'byline_sources': '', 'audience_id': '', 'original_station': [{'station': 'knxnews', 'path': 'knxnews/news/local/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}], 'syndicated_items': [{'station': '947thewave', 'path': '/947thewave/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'station': 'amp', 'path': '/amp/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'station': '931jackfm', 'path': '/931jackfm/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'station': 'kroq', 'path': '/kroq/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'station': 'kearth101', 'path': '/kearth101/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}], 'original_item': {'_index': 'published-content_v44', '_type': '_doc', '_score': None, '_source': {'date': '2020-12-21T14:21:58.468+00:00', 'lead': [{'data': {'link': None, 'name': 'CDC Study: Restaurant Diners Twice as Likely to Test Positive for COVID-19', 'video': {'id': '6190673330001', 'name': 'CDC Study: Restaurant Diners Twice as Likely to Test Positive for COVID-19', 'imageUrl': 'https://cf-images.us-east-1.prod.boltdns.net/v1/static/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/27a3573d-9fc6-494c-a493-c06271652cc8/640x360/match/image.jpg', 'm3u8Source': 'http://manifest.prod.boltdns.net/manifest/v1/hls/v4/clear/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/10s/master.m3u8?fastly_token=NjFjMWY2ODdfOWI4ZWRjYjU1ZDA3NDZkYWZiNGIxZDhmMGJkMDFhMGNjM2U1M2FmYTUyNDAzMDg3NDc2YzllNjllZTRjMzIwOQ%3D%3D', 'updated_at': '2020-11-12T17:12:06.413Z', 'delivery_type': 'dynamic_origin'}, 'views': {'views': 4558, 'redisExpiresAt': '2020-12-21T14:22:03.548Z'}, '_version': 2, 'duration': 'PT1M15.2S', 'newVideo': None, 'showTitle': False, 'bcCreatedAt': '2020-09-14T18:19:04.645Z', 'bcUpdatedAt': '2020-12-21T14:23:57.620Z', 'clickToPlay': False, 'description': "Dr. Peter Katona of UCLA's Geffen School of Medicine breaks down what a new CDC study says about dining out", 'searchVideo': {'id': '6190673330001', 'name': 'CDC Study: Restaurant Diners Twice as Likely to Test Positive for COVID-19', 'imageUrl': 'https://cf-images.us-east-1.prod.boltdns.net/v1/static/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/27a3573d-9fc6-494c-a493-c06271652cc8/640x360/match/image.jpg', 'm3u8Source': 'http://manifest.prod.boltdns.net/manifest/v1/hls/v4/clear/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/10s/master.m3u8?fastly_token=NjFjMWY2MzNfN2M5NjlkMjJjMGMxMmEyNmMwNjQ5OWJmNDJmZmZmMjY4ZDU3Njk0NWQ5YjUwMzcxN2JiZjhhNzNiMTc3NTE3OQ%3D%3D', 'updated_at': '2020-11-12T17:12:06.413Z', 'delivery_type': 'dynamic_origin'}, 'seoEmbedUrl': 'https://players.brightcove.net/5757251889001/9klBjvbUGf_default/index.html?videoId=6190673330001', 'seoHeadline': "Dr. Peter Katona of UCLA's Geffen School of Medicine breaks down what a new CDC study says about dining out", 'updateVideo': {'id': '6190673330001', 'name': 'CDC Study: Restaurant Diners Twice as Likely to Test Positive for COVID-19', 'imageUrl': 'https://cf-images.us-east-1.prod.boltdns.net/v1/static/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/27a3573d-9fc6-494c-a493-c06271652cc8/640x360/match/image.jpg', 'm3u8Source': 'http://manifest.prod.boltdns.net/manifest/v1/hls/v4/clear/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/10s/master.m3u8?fastly_token=NjFjMWY2MzNfN2M5NjlkMjJjMGMxMmEyNmMwNjQ5OWJmNDJmZmZmMjY4ZDU3Njk0NWQ5YjUwMzcxN2JiZjhhNzNiMTc3NTE3OQ%3D%3D', 'updated_at': '2020-11-12T17:12:06.413Z', 'delivery_type': 'dynamic_origin'}, 'thumbnailUrl': 'https://cf-images.us-east-1.prod.boltdns.net/v1/static/5757251889001/2ab8574c-1d48-4720-8c14-f70fc9dd7d05/27a3573d-9fc6-494c-a493-c06271652cc8/640x360/match/image.jpg', 'bcPublishedAt': '2020-09-14T18:19:04.651Z', 'seoContentUrl': 'https://www.audacy.com/_pages/ckiynais2001amuqjz81b1yfo@published', 'cacheExpiresAt': '2020-12-21T14:27:03.548Z', 'seoDescription': "Dr. Peter Katona of UCLA's Geffen School of Medicine breaks down what a new CDC study says about dining out", 'autoplayUnmuted': False, 'durationSeconds': 75, 'longDescription': None, 'componentVariation': 'brightcove'}, 'original_ref': 'www.audacy.com/_components/brightcove/instances/ckiyncbwh000z2a78vm3kjyjk@published'}], 'slug': 'opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit', 'tags': ['Outdoor dining', 'Los Angeles County', 'coronavirus'], 'feeds': {'msn': True, 'rss': True, 'postup': True, 'newsfeed': True, 'sitemaps': True, 'frequency': True, 'smartNews': True, 'apple-news': False, 'smart-news': True, 'most-popular': True, 'reversechron': True, 'google-news-feed': True}, 'hosts': [], 'adTags': {'original_ref': 'www.audacy.com/_components/ad-tags/instances/ckiynait1001kmuqjlxm9ujw7@published'}, 'byline': [{'names': [{'name': 'City News Service', 'text': 'City News Service', 'slug': 'city-news-service'}], 'sources': [], 'hosts': [], 'prefix': 'by'}], 'teaser': 'Opponents of CA’s outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit', 'authors': ['City News Service'], 'content': [{'data': {'text': "LOS ANGELES (CNS) - Opponents of the state's outdoor dining ban aimed at slowing the spread of COVID-19 have filed a federal lawsuit, two weeks after a Superior Court judge overturned a similar order in\xa0L.A. County.<br />\xa0\xa0The lawsuit comes after restaurant operators were not able to resume outdoor dining despite the Dec, 6 ruling because the state's regional stay-at- home order contains an overriding ban.<br />\xa0\xa0A team of lawyers headed by Mark J. Geragos filed the complaint Sunday in U.S. District Court asking to block the state's outdoor dining ban on behalf of the owners of the Pineapple Hill Saloon & Grill in Sherman Oaks and owner Angela Marsden, according to the complaint.<br />\xa0\xa0The complaint alleges Gov. Gavin Newsom, Attorney General Xavier Becerra and Acting State Public Health Officer Erica S. Pan, M.D. "have seized the coronavirus pandemic to expand their authority by unprecedented lengths, depriving plaintiff and all other similarly situated small business owners in California of fundamental rights protected by the U.S. and California Constitutions."<br />\xa0\xa0The complaint specifies those rights are " freedom of assembly, due process, and equal protection rights under the First and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution."<br />\xa0\xa0The complaint notes the state has prevented the Pineapple Hill Saloon & Grill from serving food outdoors while allowing a major Hollywood production to serve meals to its employees and contractors inside an outdoor tent 20 feet away from the restaurant.<br />\xa0\xa0The complaint also claims the state continues to allow the entertainment industry, major retailers, grocery stores, marijuana dispensaries and other businesses to operate indoors and outdoors.<br />\xa0\xa0The complaint asks the court for an order " temporarily, preliminarily, and permanently enjoining and prohibiting defendants from enforcing the Regional Order" as well as Executive Orders and to order the state to pay attorneys' fees and costs.", 'componentVariation': 'paragraph'}, 'original_ref': 'www.audacy.com/_components/paragraph/instances/ckiynait1001nmuqjglf3n7r9@published'}], 'feedImg': {'data': {'alt': 'Getty', 'url': 'https://images.radio.com/aiu-media/GettyImages1260671181-87539f50-6386-4869-b792-39409ac72cde.jpg', 'width': 1024, 'credit': None, 'height': 682, 'mimeType': 'image/jpeg', 'sizeInBytes': '183248', 'componentVariation': 'feed-image'}, 'original_ref': 'www.audacy.com/_components/feed-image/instances/ckiynait1001lmuqjg0epeoa3@published'}, 'sources': [], '_version': 18, 'featured': False, 'headline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'msnTitle': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'textTags': ['Outdoor dining', 'Los Angeles County', 'coronavirus'], 'pageTitle': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'sideShare': {'original_ref': 'www.audacy.com/_components/share/instances/ckiynait1001mmuqjpyfxktev@published'}, 'feedImgUrl': 'https://images.radio.com/aiu-media/GettyImages1260671181-87539f50-6386-4869-b792-39409ac72cde.jpg', 'feedLayout': 'small', 'showSocial': True, 'stationURL': 'https://www.audacy.com/knxnews', 'breadcrumbs': [{'hidden': False, 'text': 'KNX 1070 NEWSRADIO', 'url': '//www.audacy.com/knxnews'}, {'hidden': False, 'text': 'News', 'url': '//www.audacy.com/knxnews/news'}, {'hidden': False, 'text': 'Local', 'url': '//www.audacy.com/knxnews/news/local'}], 'contentType': 'article', 'stationName': 'KNX 1070 NEWSRADIO', 'stationSlug': 'knxnews', 'subHeadline': '', 'dateModified': '2020-12-21T14:23:57.580Z', 'featuredNews': False, 'sectionFront': 'news', 'fullWidthLead': False, 'syndicatedUrl': '', 'featuredSports': False, 'msnTitleLength': 57, 'stationLogoUrl': 'https://images.radio.com/logos/KNXAM.jpg', 'isContentFromAP': False, 'noIndexNoFollow': False, 'primaryHeadline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'stationCallsign': 'KNXAM', 'stationTimezone': 'PT', 'syndicationStatus': 'original', 'componentVariation': 'article', 'stationSyndication': [{'sectionFront': 'news', 'callsign': 'KTWVFM', 'stationSlug': '947thewave', 'stationName': '94.7 The WAVE', 'source': 'content subscription', 'syndicatedArticleSlug': '/947thewave/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'sectionFront': 'news', 'callsign': 'KAMPFM', 'stationSlug': 'amp', 'stationName': '97.1 AMP Radio', 'source': 'content subscription', 'syndicatedArticleSlug': '/amp/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'sectionFront': 'news', 'callsign': 'KCBSFM', 'stationSlug': '931jackfm', 'stationName': '93.1 Jack FM', 'source': 'content subscription', 'syndicatedArticleSlug': '/931jackfm/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'sectionFront': 'news', 'callsign': 'KROQFM', 'stationSlug': 'kroq', 'stationName': 'KROQ', 'source': 'content subscription', 'syndicatedArticleSlug': '/kroq/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}, {'sectionFront': 'news', 'callsign': 'KRTHFM', 'stationSlug': 'kearth101', 'stationName': 'K-EARTH 101', 'source': 'content subscription', 'syndicatedArticleSlug': '/kearth101/news/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit'}], 'rollingStandoutCount': 0, 'secondarySectionFront': 'local', 'plaintextPrimaryHeadline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'canBeMarkedGoogleStandout': True, 'availableStandoutArticleInventory': True, 'articleWithinGoogleStandoutPublishDateLimit': True, 'canonicalUrl': 'http://www.audacy.com/knxnews/news/local/opponents-of-cas-outdoor-dining-ban-file-federal-lawsuit', 'site': 'demo', 'manualSlugUnlock': False, 'plaintextShortHeadline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'seoHeadline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'pageDescription': 'Opponents of the state’s outdoor dining ban aimed at slowing the spread of COVID-19 have filed a federal lawsuit, two weeks after a Superior Court judge overturned a similar order in L.A. County.', 'seoDescription': 'Opponents of the state’s outdoor dining ban aimed at slowing the spread of COVID-19 have filed a federal lawsuit, two weeks after a Superior Court judge overturned a similar order in L.A. County.', 'shortHeadline': "Opponents of CA's outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit", 'evergreenSlug': None, 'slugLock': True, 'socialDescription': 'Opponents of CA’s outdoor dining ban file federal lawsuit'}, 'sort': [483884], 'stationSlug': '931jackfm', 'original_id': 'www.audacy.com/_components/article/instances/ckiynait1001omuqjv6s7galg@published'}}
Skip to content




