Mitchell's Ice Cream is issuing a voluntary recall after an allergen may be included in up to 172 pints of the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup ice cream which may instead contain Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel Yogurt which contains wheat, an ingredient not listed in the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. This could be an issue to those with a wheat allergen.
If you purchased a pint of the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup ice cream between January 6th and January 17th from any of the shops or grocery stores listen below, it may contain a wheat allergen.
Mitchell’s Ice Cream shops in:
-Ohio City
-Strongsville
-Beachwood
-Rocky River
-Van Aken
-Westlake
Grocery Stores:
-Heinen’s: Mayfield, Mentor, University Heights, Strongsville, Avon, Bainbridge, Shaker Heights, Aurora, Willoughby, Middleburg Heights, Chagrin Falls, Twinsburg, Hudson, Brecksville, Bay Village, Downtown, Pepper Pike
-Giant Eagle: Avon Lake, Westlake, Rocky River, Tanglewood, Avon Lake
-Mustard Seed: Montrose, Highland Square
-Dave’s Markets: Ohio City, Severance
-Constantinos Downtown
-Lake Road Market
-Lucky’s Market in Cleveland
-Rego's in Strongsville
-Boardwalk Neighborhood Market
-New Creation Farm
If you aren't sure if you received the right pint, Mitchell's Ice Cream released a statement on Instagram and stated that the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup ice cream is dark brown in color, whereas Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel Yogurt is light brown.
If you have a mislabeled pint, please contact Mitchell’s Ice Cream at info@mitchellshomemade.com.





