Graziano: Trading For Andy Greene Isn't Enough

75756A5E-120A-4932-810C-2FD980DB785E

The New York Islanders are floundering, the cushion created by a 16-3-1 start all but gone after last night’s 3-1 loss to the Colorado Avalanche ended a four-game road trip. They have now been passed in the standings by the Philadelphia Flyers and Carolina Hurricanes and are tied with the Columbus Blue Jackets. They sit only six points better than the ‘rebuilding’ New York Rangers in the final wild card spot.

With the season-ending injury to Adam Pelech and the defense taking a considerable downturn over the past 15 games, the much-needed trade by president and general manager Lou Lamoriello to get Andy Greene is simply not enough. Yes, it takes some critical minutes away from a struggling Noah Dobson and will lighten the load on Nick Leddy, Devon Toews, Ryan Pulock and Johnny Boychuk, who have all felt the strain of increased assignments and tougher consistent matchups. It does nothing to address an offensive drought that has reached epic proportions.

There are some who say this the deal can only benefit the Islanders on the offensive end with calmer blueline play and an improved breakout. Good defense equals good offense, right? With the Islanders, that’s not necessarily the case. They led the league in goals against last season and still struggled to score goals, leading head coach Barry Trotz to announce that as his teams biggest need after their playoff loss to Carolina.

Oct 28, 2018; Raleigh, NC, USA; New York Islanders head coach Barry Trotz (right) looks on from behind the players bench against the Carolina Hurricanes at PNC Arena. Mandatory Credit: James Guillory-USA TODAY SportsUSA TODAY Sports

Right now, the trade market seems as expensive as its ever been, with a good return found on Tyler Toffoli and Blake Coleman as starters. With Cal Clutterbuck and Casey Cizikas both still out of the lineup with skate lacerations, Lamoriello might be wise to shift away from the Chris Kreider and JG Pageau’s of the world and set his sights on filling in his bottom six with players such as Vladislav Namestnikov, Derek Grant or Barclay Goodrow. Or do nothing.

While those are far from sexy name acquisitions, they all could fill a defensive, penalty killing, faceoff roll for New York.  The top-six forward appears to be out of reach and out of Lamoriello’s comfort zone for balancing the present with the future. Everyone wants to believe they are last season’s St. Louis Blues and who am I to say your team isn’t? But take a realistic look at the Islanders, and all their pluses and minuses, and go from there. Do you truly believe they are a player away?

As far as the play on the ice, they started out okay, dropping a game to the scorching Tampa Bay Lightning before rallying to defeat the Washington Capitals and Flyers. What did they do for an encore? Score two goals in their next four on the trip, losing to the Nashville Predators, Vegas Golden Knights, Phoenix Coyotes and Avalanche. That’s four of a possible 14 points. It’s their first regulation losing streak of more than two games under Trotz (now sitting at four).

As I wrote last week, I’m just not sure who this team is at the present time. It’s something Trotz and Lamoriello must figure out before Monday’s trade deadline to properly execute their strategy, whatever that ends up being.

The Islanders celebrate after a goal by right wing Jordan Eberle against the New Jersey Devils on Jan. 7, 2020, at the Prudential Center.Ed Mulholland/USA TODAY Images

Greene’s first game as an Islander was a success, even though the team dropped a 2-1 decision to the Coyotes. He came exactly as advertised - calm, cool and collected, fitting in seamlessly on the left side with Ryan Pulock. For good measure, the defensive-minded Greene even collected an assist on Anthony Beauvillier’s third-period goal across 19:46 of ice time (2:32 on the penalty kill). He followed that up with another 16:30 last night (3:12 on the PK) and blocked three shots.

“I really liked his game,” Trotz said to Newsday after Monday’s contest. “It’s what the doctor ordered. He’s poised. I thought he handled their top line [which includes Greene’s former Devils teammate, Taylor Hall] and he’s a good complement for Pully. It’ll definitely be a good fit for us.”

I’m not sure if Greene can hang around long enough to see 1,000 games (he’s currently at 924), but that kind of experience, longevity, durability and professionalism is exactly what Lamoriello and Trotz covet. It was an opportunity to bring someone in that wouldn’t have to be coddled or explained how ‘things work.’ Greene has seen it all, been well ‘around the block’. A pro’s pro, if you will.

Follow Andy on Twitter: @AndyGraz_WFAN