Evan is headed to Madison Square Garden for Knicks Cavaliers, but his game night plan quickly turns into classic New York sports chaos. From taking Big Mac after Craig backed out, to defending the Chase Bridge seats, to admitting he may bring his Mets scorebook into the building, Evan and Tiki Barber set the stage for a very unusual Eastern Conference Finals experience.
The conversation also digs into Mets fans ripping Joe Davis for his “Oh no, the Mets” call, Evan’s belief that Davis sounds too much like a Dodgers fan, and the latest Yankees concerns after a rough series. The guys debate whether this Yankees team should ever be compared to the 1998 club, what the Mets do when key players eventually return, and why both New York baseball teams still have major questions to answer.
May 18, 2026
