Virginia vs. Texas Tech is a gift to those who love great defense

Cover Image
Photo credit USA TODAY Sports

From the moment Virginia and Texas Tech punched their tickets to tonight's college basketball national championship game the chorus of internet naysayers swarmed in front of their keyboards across the country.  

Boring!
Will set basketball back a generation.
A nightmare for ratings.
Who wants to watch this?

Those are just some of the more mundane comments you'll see littered across social media right now in discussing this title game that features two of the three best defensive teams in the country.  In fact, Texas Tech is not only the best defensive team in the country this season but the best in the past 18 seasons, according to Ken Pomeroy.  Virginia, always a dominant defensive group under coach Tony Bennett, looks a bit pedestrian in comparison even though the Commodores have allowed just 59.2 points per game to their opponents in this tournament.  True to form, the Red Raiders top that by allowing just 55.8 points to their opponents during the tournament.

Yes, this championship game features great defense.  No, these teams are unlikely to eclipse the 70 point mark -- heck, the 60 point mark is probably a bit of a stretch.  That doesn't make this game any less intriguing for fans who aren't petty, and foolish, enough to tune out because Joe Troll on Twitter told you so.  

College basketball has enjoyed an offensive revolution the past handful of years.  The freedom of movement rules have allowed teams like Duke, North Carolina, Villanova, Kansas, and Gonzaga to score at an incredibly efficient rate during their dominant runs this decade.  Those high-flying teams traditionally make deep runs in the tournament.  Heck, they usually win it -- see the UNC and Villanova title runs in the past three years.

That the sport still has room for a myriad of styles to be highly successful is only a great thing for the future of college basketball.  The armchair point guards sitting at home in their chairs while screaming WE NEED MORE OFFENSE either haven't been paying attention to the transformation of college hoops recently, or are just making noise for the sake of making noise.  Highly skilled offense isn't going anywhere at the elite level of college basketball.  

The people complaining about Virginia vs. Texas Tech probably wouldn't like the result of every college basketball program investing on the offensive end, while ditching fundamentals and execution on the defensive side.  It's hard to believe that the NCAA tournament would be nearly as fun if all 68 teams could score 100 points per contest but couldn't effectively defend a handful of solid intramural players.  The variety and diversity of teams and systems in the tournament are what make it so unique, so valuable, and so beloved.  

This would be a bit like complaining that elite NFL defenses can still be successful.  Are we supposed to chastise the current Chicago Bears defense?  Was the Legion of Boom bad for the NFL?  I don't hear anybody taking shots at the 1985 Bears or the Steel Curtain Steelers.   Are baseball fans now going to lament every time Clayton Kershaw, Justin Verlander, Jacob deGrom or other dominant starters take the mound?  

Why is it that fans only hate defense when college basketball is the discussion?  It's just more of the same bizarre groupthink by the masses that is also plaguing discussions around movies and video games.  Because it's not what fans are used to, because what they're seeing is different, many people automatically think it's a bad product.  None of those things correlate.  The only thing that's bad here is that people pay attention to the loudest critical voices instead of the most reasoned ones.

So this college basketball season will be capped off tonight by a defensive struggle for the ages.  We'll have a dozen or more Carolina-vs-Villanova-type championship games in our future before we get another Virginia vs. Texas Tech.  Are you really going to be upset that you get to watch something a bit different this year?