A pair of early turnovers set the tone for the day and late pass interference penalty set up the Panthers' 54-yard game-winning field goal in a lackluster, frustrating, deflating 20-17 loss at the Caesars Superdome.
"Frustration, disappointment," head coach Kellen Moore said of the mood in the locker room. "We had a great opportunity. No one is going to feel sorry for you. ... You have to get this right and then you have to move forward."
The Saints offense gained just 222 yards and reached the red zone twice, though they did score touchdowns on both visits. Quarterback Tyler Shough completed 25 of 35 passes for 187 yards, a touchdown, and an interception. Shough was also the Saints' leading rusher with 25 yards on six carries. It was another anemic day on the ground for New Orleans, with the trio of Alvin Kamara, Audric Estime and Travis Etienne combining for 24 yards on 17 attempts. Kamara scored both Saints touchdowns and added 10 yards on three catches.
The Saints busiest offensive piece on the day was rookie Jordyn Tyson, who caught 11 passes for 80 yards in his second career game.
Panthers running back Chubba Hubbard was the star of the game, leading Carolina in both rushing and receiving. Hubbard ran for 92 yards and two touchdowns on 24 carries and caught five passes for 80 yards, including a pair of long gains on screen passes to set up a touchdown after New Orleans had claimed its first lead of the day, 14-10, with just under 4 minutes remaining. Quarterback Bryce Young completed 17 out of 30 passes for 200 yards.
"It feels awful," Shough said. "It's a missed opportunity. We have to beat those guys. That wasn't a win by them -- they're obviously a good team -- but we felt like we lost that game as the Saints."
The first half was, for the most part, a comedy of errors.
The Saints turned the ball over twice, surrendering the only touchdown of the half off the second giveaway. On the Saints' opening drive, Panthers linebacker Devin Lloyd intercepted a tipped Shough pass intended for Olave, returning it 41 yards. However, the Saints defense kept the Panthers' offense out of the end zone, stopping the drive at the 3 yard line when Carl Granderson sacked Young to force a turnover on downs.
After a series of punts and a missed Carolina field goal, the Saints gave the ball back to the Panthers when linebacker Jaelan Phillips recovered a fumbled Shough handoff to Estime. Eleven plays and 56 yards later, the Panthers found the end zone on a two-yard Hubbard run on 4th down, putting Carolina ahead with 6:46 remaining in the half.
The Saints' offense appeared to gain some momentum on the next drive, but that drive stalled just outside the red zone. Carolina recorded a fourth-down stop of its own when the defensive lineman Lee Hunter stopped Estime for a loss of a yard to force a turnover on downs with 3:17 left in the second quarter.
In all, the Saints offense gained 107 yards in the first half. Carolina's offense recorded 173 offensive yards in the first 30 minutes.
The Saints defense opened the second half with a bang, stopping Carolina's opening drive with a third-down sack. Linebacker Colby Wooden dropped Young for a six-yard loss. The Saints' offense capitalized on the stop, scoring to tie the game on the ensuing nine-play, 49-yard drive.
Carolina responded with a score of their own, taking a 10-7 lead four minutes later when Fitzgerald drilled a 55-yard field goal.
The game turned into a stalemate after that field goal, with the teams trading a series of punts over the next four possessions. The Saints finally broke through thanks in part to two critical Carolina penalties. A horse collar tackle turned what would have been a Saints 4th down inside Carolina territory into a fresh set of downs. Several plays later, a pass interference call gave the Saints the ball inside the five-yard line. Kamara scored on a four-yard reception to give New Orleans its first lead of the day. The Panthers were flagged 17 times for 159 yards in the game.
That lead lasted until 1:49 left in the fourth quarter. Hubbard closed out a six-play, 68-yard drive with a one-yard touchdown run to put Carolina ahead by a 17-14 margin. Hubbard helped set up his own score with two big catches earlier in the drive, one for 29 yards after LB Kaden Elliss missed on a tackle attempt and another for 34 yards to put the ball just outside the goal line.
"I really feel like I could have ended that game there and I did not," Elliss said. "It's just frustrating because I think that ... the defense fought really hard, played really hard the whole game. At the end you've got to come through."
The Saints quickly drove inside Carolina territory and set up kicker Charlie Smyth, who hit a 55-yard field goal to tie the game at 17-17 with 45 seconds remaining in the game. Just a few plays later, a pass interference call against Kool-Aid McKinstry put the Panthers in position for the game-winning field goal.
The Saints (3-6) play at the Chicago Bears (7-2) next week. The Panthers (4-5) will host the Baltimore Ravens (4-5) next Sunday.




