Opening Observations: Indians lose to White Sox 8-0 in must-win game

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - SEPTEMBER 26: Yasiel Puig #66 of the Cleveland Indians is unable to catch the RBI triple by Jose Abreu #79 of the Chicago White Sox during the fifth inning of a game at Guaranteed Rate Field on September 26, 2019 in Chicago, Illinois.
Photo credit Photo by Nuccio DiNuzzo/Getty Images
CLEVELAND, OH – The Indians knew what was at stake on Thursday night. Their playoffs lives were on the line. They needed to win to keep any realistic chance to earn a Wild Card spot alive.

They got off to a decent start. Aaron Civale didn’t allow a hit in the first three innings. They didn’t score, but they had three hits in the first two innings.

Unfortunately for the Tribe, things crumbled from there. The White Sox hit two home runs in the fourth inning, including a 3-run shot from James McCann that instantly put the game in doubt for Cleveland.

Civale had allowed two home runs in 58⅓ innings coming into the game. That number doubled in two pitches. 

It was just the start for Chicago, who ended up scoring at least one run in four straight innings en route to an 8-0 lead.

The Indians couldn’t put together any sort of rally at the plate. In fact, their offense was nonexistent for most of the game. The White Sox retired 17 straight Indians hitters starting with Francisco Lindor’s line drive to right field that ended the second inning. Greg Allen broke up the streak with a single in the eighth inning.

It was an unexpected bullpen game for Chicago. Dylan Cease was supposed to be on the mound, but he was an unexpected scratch. Jose Ruiz opened for Chicago, tossing 1⅔ innings. The White Sox used four pitchers on the night.

It was the 14th time the Indians had been shutout in 2019. The White Sox went 11-8 in head-to-head matchups with the Tribe this season. 

Top of the Order Struggles

The Indians’ first five hitters were 1-for-39 in the final two games of this series. Both Oscar Mercado and Yasiel Puig had been on fire at the plate, but they couldn’t get anything going against the White Sox.

Lindor was as bad as anyone in this series. He finished 1-for-14 with eight strikeouts. The four-time All-Star couldn’t cash in on key opportunities with runners in scoring position.
The Indians have scored three runs in their last 22 innings against the White Sox. That’s never ideal, but it’s even worse when you’re relying on young pitchers to get the job done in critical situations.

Playoff Chances

The Indians need a lot of help if they’re going to find their way into the playoffs. They aren’t mathematically eliminated, but they’re officially on life support.

Cleveland has to sweep the Nationals this weekend in Washington. They also need the Rays to lose two of three games against the Blue Jays to tie Tampa Bay for the second Wild Card spot. They are two games behind the Rays going into Friday.