PHILADELPHIA (KYW Newsradio) — Members of the Pennsylvania State House LGBTQ+ Equality Caucus are pushing back on President Donald Trump’s stance against protecting the rights of transgender people. The president on Tuesday signed an executive order aimed at cutting federal support for gender transitions for people under age 19.
“It is the policy of the United States that it will not fund, sponsor, promote, assist, or support the so-called 'transition' of a child from one sex to another, and it will rigorously enforce all laws that prohibit or limit these destructive and life-altering procedures,” the order says.
It’s his latest in a series of targeted moves to roll back protections for transgender people across the country.
Trump began his second term with a flurry of executive orders, including one that seeks to define sex as only male or female, not recognizing transgender, nonbinary or intersex people or the idea that gender can be fluid. Trump’s order called it an issue of women’s rights, and said transgender ideology denies “the biological reality of sex”.
Already that's resulted in the State Department halting issuing passports with an “X” gender marker, forcing transgender people to apply for travel documents with markers that don't match their identities.
“He’s continued to try to erase the existence of trans people in this country, and it’s horrifying,” said state Rep. Andre Carroll, who serves parts of Philadelphia and is a member of the caucus.
“We have to make sure that we’re doing things to make sure that we protect people to be able to live quality lives so we’re not leaving them in the pathway of danger.”
In 2023 the Democrat-controlled Pennsylvania House passed the Fairness Act to try and strengthen protections against anti-queer discrimination. The bill did not pass the Senate, but Carroll expects it to be re-introduced in this session.
“That bill simply aimed to make sure that everyone had equal opportunities [and] protections around employment,” said Carroll.
“Unfortunately right now we’re faced with an administration that is committed to the regression of this country.”
Carroll says despite his disagreements with the federal government, he and his fellow caucus members can craft legislation to help the commonwealth.
“One thing that Trump says often is, ‘Leave it to the states’. As a state lawmaker I’m committed to making sure, on a state level, we’re doing everything to protect every single Pennsylvanian, including our trans people.”
Monday, Trump ordered Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to revise the agency’s policy on transgender troops, which may lead to an all-out ban from military service. A group of active-duty military personnel sued over that on Tuesday.
Tuesday’s executive order targeting transgender Americans directs federally-run insurance programs, including TRICARE for military families and Medicaid, to exclude coverage for gender-affirming care and calls on the Department of Justice to vigorously pursue litigation and legislation to oppose the practice.
Medicaid programs in some states cover such care. The new order suggests that the practice could end, and targets hospitals and universities that receive federal money and provide the care.
The language in the executive order — using words such as “maiming,” “sterilizing” and “mutilation” — contradicts what is typical for gender-affirming care in the United States. It also labels guidance from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health as “junk science.” Major medical groups such as the American Medical Association support access to care.
“Parents and families should be free to make medical decisions informed by their doctors and the available science without the interference of politics,” an American Academy of Pediatrics spokesperson said.
Young people who persistently identify as a gender that differs from their sex assigned at birth are first evaluated by a team of professionals. Some young people may try a social transition, involving changing a hairstyle or pronouns. Some may later also receive puberty blockers or hormones. Surgery is extremely rare for minors.
“This executive order is a brazen attempt to put politicians in between people and their doctors, preventing them from accessing evidence-based health care supported by every major medical association in the country,” Human Rights Campaign President Kelley Robinson said in a statement. “It is deeply unfair to play politics with people’s lives and strip transgender young people, their families and their providers of the freedom to make necessary health care decisions.”
Trump's order is likely to be challenged in court, as many of his policies have been.
The order has families of transgender young people wondering what comes next.
“Our biggest fear is for our daughter. Will she be able to get the care that she needs,” said Melissa Baern, a Massachusetts mother of a transgender 18-year-old daughter who is on hormone therapy. “And if she doesn’t get the care she needs, what does that mean for her? What does that mean for her mental health?”
The push is the latest by Trump to reverse policies by the Biden administration to protect transgender people and their care. On Monday, Trump directed the Pentagon to conduct a review that is likely to lead to them being barred from military service. A group of active-duty military personnel sued over that on Tuesday.
Trump said he would address these issues during his campaign last year, and his actions could prove widely divisive.
In the November election, voters were slightly more likely to oppose than support laws that ban gender-affirming medical treatment, such as puberty blockers and hormone therapy, for minors under the age of 18 who identify as transgender, according to AP VoteCast. About half of voters, 52%, were opposed, but 47% said they were in favor.
Trump’s voters were much more likely to support bans on transgender care: About 6 in 10 Trump voters favored such laws.
“It’s very clear that this order, in combination with the other orders that we’ve seen over the past week, are meant to not protect anyone in this country, but rather to single-mindedly drive out transgender people of all ages from all walks of civic life,” said Harper Seldin, a staff attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union’s LGBTQ & HIV Project.
Seldin said the ACLU is reviewing the order “to understand what, if anything, has immediate effect versus what needs to go through continued agency action.”
Even as transgender people have gained visibility and acceptance on some fronts, they've become major targets for social conservatives. In recent years, at least 26 states have adopted laws restricting or banning gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors. And most of those states face lawsuits, including one over Tennessee's ban that's pending before the U.S. Supreme Court.
Republican-controlled states have also moved to keep transgender women and girls from competing in women's or girls’ sports and to dictate which bathrooms transgender people can use, particularly in schools.