The New Orleans Saints ran into some very familiar issues in their 20-17 loss to the Carolina Panthers this week.
The run game? Nonexistent. Turnovers? Too many. Takeaways? Not enough. Clutch defensive stops? Not this time. The Saints are 3-6 and now turn to what is undoubtedly their most difficult road trip of the season.
With all that in mind, scroll below for our stock up and stock down players after Week 10.
STOCK DOWN
RUN GAME CONSISTENCY
It would be easy to heap all of the run game issues in this game on a patchwork offensive line. That certainly played a major role in why things couldn't get going, but such is life in the NFL. Players get hurt. Roles change. Good teams find a way.
The Saints simply are not a good team, or at least they don't play like one nearly enough of the time. They're 2-2 in their last four games.
In the wins: 235 yards on 70 carries (4.8 YPC)
In the losses: 66 yards on 40 carries (1.6 YPC)
Travis Etienne is back healthy and that should help things down the line, but not on this day. What the made the performance even more troubling was the opponent. The Steelers are a good run front. The Panthers? They walked into this game ranked 28th and allowing 134 yards per game on the ground.
Is your refrigerator running? Ours is ‼️#CARvsNO📺 FOX https://t.co/IEDAkmFKPF
— Carolina Panthers (@Panthers) November 15, 2026
It's difficult to assign blame without really digging into the film, but a common denominator from both of those losses was rookie Jeremiah Wright starting at right guard. He's a solid, young, developmental player, but there's clearly still a lot of development needed. The Saints could've avoided putting him back into a starting role, but felt the best option was to move Cesar Ruiz to center rather than go with backup center Will Sherman. It's impossible to know exactly what it would've looked like with Sherman in there, but if McCoy misses another week, that road has to at least be considered.
Losing Fuaga late in the week was also a serious blow. One would have to wonder if the Saints might've gone a different route had they been able to foresee that absence.
Regardless, the Saints fired TJ Paganetti and cut Kendre Miller in the hopes of fixing an often anemic run game. Clearly they didn't get to the root of the problem.
SHUTDOWN DEFENSE
This is something I ranted about a good bit going into the game, so I can't just stop now. A season-long theme has been taken to the extreme over the past two weeks: When the Saints defense desperately needs a stop, they simply can't find it.
Here's what that's looked like:
WEEK 9
- Saints kick field goal to take 9-6 lead, 5:44 remaining in 4th quarter; Next Browns drive: 1 play, 64 yards (64-yard Concepcion TD)
- Saints score TD to take 16-13 lead, 0:53 remaining in 4th quarter; Next Browns drive: 7 plays, 41 yards (51-yard FG-good)
- Saints score TD to take 23-16 lead, 4:12 remaining in OT; Next Browns drive: 8 plays, 67 yards (39-yard Fannin TD)
WEEK 10
- Saints score touchdown to take 14-10 lead, 3:43 remaining in 4th quarter; Next Panthers drive: 6 plays, 68 yards (1-yard Hubbard TD)
- Saints score FG to tie game at 17-17, 0:34 remaining in 4th quarter; Next Panthers drive: 3 plays, 30 yards (54-yard FG-good)
Five situations. Four of them were the only times in those games where the defense was pinned to a lead. Three turned into touchdowns. One was a busted coverage and poor angles. Another saw two broken tackles. Another saw more missed tackles and two long catch and run plays by the running back. The other was aided by a tough defensive pass interference penalty. But it adds to the ongoing theme.
It's tough to even call any players out by name because so many have had a hand in it somewhere. Today the biggest culprit was Kaden Elliss with a critical missed tackle on Hubbard. He was also arguably the Saints defensive player in the game with 15 combined tackles and a sack.
And I'll say it again, these aren't the only examples, just what we've seen the past two weeks. This Saints defense has a lot of juice when playing from behind. They've kept the Saints in most of their games this season and given the offense a chance to do something special late in the game. But they've been atrocious at playing with the lead. Maybe it's a product of not being put in that situation often enough. I don't know, but it's brutal to watch play out and only seems to be getting worse.
TAKEAWAYS? NOPE, ONLY GIVEAWAYS
This is a twofer because I simply don't know how else to explain it. We hear all the time that turnover margin is one of the biggest determining factors in winning and losing. That part is true. The Saints can simply never get on the right side of it.
That's due to a few reasons, one being that in five of their nine games this season that's been impossible to do. The Saints haven't forced a takeaway since they picked off JJ McCarthy in the 4th quarter against the Giants. It was one of three takeaways in that game. They also forced a pair of fumbles against the Vikings, picked off Lamar Jackson and stole a ball away from Jahmyr Gibbs in the opener. As far as the defense is concerned, that's it. There have also been a pair of special teams takeaways (Raiders and Giants).
Against the Panthers there didn't even seem to be any near misses. The opportunities just weren't there.
If only that was the case on the other side of the ball. The Saints currently lead the NFL with 10 fumbles lost and their 17 total giveaways is the 5th most in the NFL. Their differential of -8 is the 4th worst.
This week featured another pair of giveaways. One was on 4th down when Shough tried to force a ball into Chris Olave on 4th down. The need to throw the ball in that situation is telling in and of itself. The ball bounced into the arms of Devin Lloyd who returned it deep into Saints territory. The Saints defense has stood on its head at the goal line to keep points off the board the last two weeks, but that's a tough way to live.
RUN DEVIN RUN#CARvsNO📺 FOX https://t.co/bB9w0BJGVh
— Carolina Panthers (@Panthers) November 15, 2026
Later in the half it was a botched RPO between Shough and Audric Estime. The QB put the blame on himself, but he'd do that regardless. Estime declined to talk about the play after the game. Based on his slow reaction after the ball came loose, he certainly didn't look like he expected to have the ball. Regardless, the Panthers took over in a 0-0 game and drove for a touchdown and the lone points of the first half.
FUMBLE! Recovered by Phillips 🔥#CARvsNO📺 FOX https://t.co/2VFzw5l9J8
— Carolina Panthers (@Panthers) November 15, 2026
The Saints simply don't do the things that you'd point to and call winning football, even in a game where the opponent was penalties an astounding 17 times for 152 yards.
A FEW MORE
- The Saints are fully committed to Tyler Shough and it's the right call, but I don't think we've seen the best version of the player over the past month. Whether it's due to some injuries, a lack of a consistent run game, constant pressure or some combination of the three, we've seen a lot of frenetic QB play from a player who earned the job by looking beyond his years in terms of poise under pressure. We're still talking about a player in his second season who just finished his 18th career start, but the growth seems to have been stunted of late. I assure you, the plays sent in for the final drive were not "check down three times and hope for a flag." The quarterback isn't trusting what he's seeing. That's a problem and I don't expect the film review to be kind.
- The Saints were expected to feature their tight ends a good bit this season. Early in the year that was the case, and the offense looked its best. Lately? Not so much. Juwan Johnson seems to only be targeted on scramble plays. Noah Fant was targeted one time and couldn't catch the ball thrown a bit behind him. Oscar Delp has four total catches and none since Week 6.
- Alvin Kamara has always been a guy who'd prefer to avoid a hit when possible. When he was the star and engine of the offense I was a lot more accepting of it. In this case it created the game-losing scenario when instead of putting his shoulder into the defender and fighting for yards while keeping the clock running, he veered toward the edge of the field and dove for a few extra yards. He might have turned a 58-yard attempt into a 55-yard attempt, but it allowed the Panthers to keep their timeout. Odds are they don't attack the middle of the field the way they did without that. It's possible the Panthers still find a way, regardless, but it's a frustrating trend that has created more difficult scenarios.
STOCK UP
1. TYSON'S WORKLOAD
This certainly wasn't the most dynamic 11-catch day you'll ever see. A lot of it was near the line of scrimmage. There was a lot of running, but only 80 yards of production.
Still, the dynamic ability is there and we're only scratching the surface. There was also one 20-yard explosive play and some nice catches in traffic. If I'm concerned about anything it's just how little action Chris Olave saw. Finding a way to keep both player engaged will be a challenge, and not one that I'm necessarily confident this staff will handle all that well.
Still, the No. 8 overall pick with major injury concerns took on a huge workload in this game and handled it just fine. The Saints won't be folding up shop if this season doesn't go where they want it to. Tyson will be a huge piece of getting this thing back on track, and this is the type of week that should build confidence in that long-term reality.
2. CLUTCH CHARLIE
For once we can leave a game not complaining about the kicker.
I don't know if it's because the kick was from the right hash or maybe even just because Charlie Smyth is at his most confident kicking late against the Panthers, but the Saints asked their young kicker to attempt a 55-yarder with the game on the line and he nailed it.
There are a lot of things to complain about in this game. He's not one of them. It sure would be nice if the Saints can at least say they've found a long-term kicker in this frustrating, ugly season. Early returns have been positive.
3. STOPPING BRYCE
This game was the best Bryce Young has looked against the Saints, that's not saying much. He finished the day with exactly 200 yards passing, with 63 of those yards coming on a late drive on balls to Chuba Hubbard near the line of scrimmage.
What you can say is he didn't turn the ball over, but that seems more of a Saints symptom than a Bryce achievement. He was clearly antsy in the pocket and trying to get the ball out quickly, and it means VERY little downfield passing or efficiency. He completed just 17 of his 30 pass attempts and was sacked three times. The big Panthers offensive play to set up their game-winning field goal was an underthrown ball into double coverage that drew a flag because Kool-Aid McKinstry didn't stop to look for it hitting him in the back.
Tyler Shough said after the game he didn't feel like the Panthers won the game, but that the Saints lost it. Well, I can tell you one thing, Bryce Young was on the winning side, but he didn't win this game. The Saints still, clearly, have his number. One of these weeks they might even get out of their own way.
HONORABLE MENTION
- Even with the hard-luck DPI on an underthrown ball late in the game, one thing that the Saints can certainly point to as a positive this season has been limiting penalties. They had three total in this game for 46 yards. At one point late in the 4th quarter the Panthers actually had more total penalties (17) than Saints penalty yards. All three penalties were in the secondary (holding on Quincy Riley, DPI on Martin Emerson and DPI on McKinstry). Despite all the changes on the OL, the Saints didn't have a single procedural miscue. The Saints' 52 accepted penalties against in the third fewest in the NFL. Small victories, I guess.
- Alvin Kamara gets the rare honor of appearing on both ends of this column. There was a point in this game where Alvin Kamara had three touches and two touchdowns. Goal line efficiency was anything but a given in this game, and he battled in for stress-free TDs (one rushing and one receiving) both times the Saints needed it. Not the role I expected him to have, but it was effective in this game. I know I'd have been stressing if either of those situations got to third down.
- I thought this was one of Jonas Sanker's better games. He held up in coverage and has tackled well in the run game all season. Whether his future is in the slot or as a deep safety, feel like he's a solid, young piece that will only keep getting better.




