Washington, D.C. (WBEN/AP) - Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle said Monday that her agency failed in its mission to protect former President Donald Trump, as lawmakers that make up the House Oversight and Accountability Committee demanded answers during a highly contentious hearing.
The hearing also drew calls for Cheatle's resignation over security failures on July 13, 2024 that allowed a gunman to scale a roof and open fire at Trump's campaign rally in Butler, Pa.
Cheatle was berated for hours by both Republican and Democratic lawmakers, repeatedly angering elected officials by evading questions about the investigation during the first hearing over the July 13 assassination attempt. Cheatle called the attempt on Trump’s life the Secret Service’s "most significant operational failure" in decades, and vowed to "move heaven and earth" to get to the bottom of what went wrong and make sure there’s no repeat of it.
"The Secret Service’s solemn mission is to protect our nation’s leaders. On July 13, we failed," Cheatle told lawmakers on the House Oversight Committee.
Related
Cheatle acknowledged that the Secret Service was told about a suspicious person two-to-five times before the shooting at the rally. She also revealed that the roof from which Thomas Matthew Crooks opened fire had been identified as a potential vulnerability days before the rally. Cheatle said she apologized to Trump in a phone call after the assassination attempt.
Yet, Cheatle remained defiant that she was the "right person" to lead the Secret Service, even as she took full responsibility for any security lapses at the event.
In a rare moment of unity for the often divided committee, the Republican chairman, Rep. James Comer, and its top Democrat, Rep. Jamie Raskin, issued a letter calling on Cheatle to step down.
The White House didn’t immediately comment on whether President Joe Biden still has confidence in Cheatle after her testimony.
Democrats and Republicans were united in their exasperation as Cheatle said she didn’t know, or couldn’t answer numerous questions more than a week after the shooting that left one spectator dead.
Western New York Congressman Nick Langworthy (R-NY-23) was among the lawmakers in Washington in attendance for Monday's hearing, and was openly critical of the actions of Cheatle and the role the Secret Service played on July 13.
He started by noting a trip to Butler, Pa. in preparation for Monday's hearing, and to formulate some questions about the events of the assassination attempt on the former President's life.
"I was absolutely appalled when I went to the site when I saw the fact that I could have stood on the roof of that building, the AGR building, and hit that podium with a 9-iron, and I'm a lousy golfer. And the fact that was not included in the perimeter is a complete dereliction of the duty of the U.S. Secret Service," said Langworthy. "There are very few rooftops that needed to be secured, and the fact that the Secret Service, as they were putting a site plan in place, did not think it was necessary to man those rooftops, you have completely walked away from your duty. You had one job, and that's to protect the future President of the United States, or to protect all of the other protectees. And President Trump is only here today by God's grace, because he had just something in him that made him turn his head just slightly, or we would be in a national period of mourning right now."
After listening to several other lawmakers speak before him on Monday, Langworthy said he was forced to rewrite his questions a number of times because Cheatle had not given an answer to other questions brought to her attention.
"You haven't given any information. You have hidden behind this FBI investigation, and I think you should be ashamed of yourself. You have brought more shame to your agency than I think the assassination attempt has, at this point," Langworthy stated. "This is literally the worst performance I have ever seen in front of a Congressional hearing. You have offered no reason for this committee, this body or the American people to trust you or the Secret Service today. And you should resign."
Langworthy calls out Cheatle for a lack of accountability on her part in light of the assassination attempt of Trump nine days prior.
"Not one person has been suspended, not one person has been put on a desk. Meanwhile, we've got the most contentious of elections in our nation's history, and protectees are in danger because of incompetent leadership," he said. "Not the agents. The agents piled on President Trump to protect his life. Those are heroes, but the administrators running your agency, they're not right now. They're not doing their jobs, and you certainly aren't doing [your job]."
Langworthy feels the most appalling part of the events leading up to the shooting was the countless opportunities the Secret Service had to stop Crooks before he got on the roof of the building he pulled the trigger on.
"At 3 o'clock, Crooks raised suspicion by entering the rally with a rangefinder. At 5:45, a cop with the Beaver County Emergency Services Unit saw Crooks eyeballing the roof at the AGR International building, and then at 5:55, Secret Service was warned of a suspicious person and identifies Crooks as a threat. This was all before shots were fired 15 minutes later," Langworthy detailed.
Lawmakers pressed Cheatle on how the gunman could get so close to the Republican presidential nominee when he was supposed to be carefully guarded, and why Trump was allowed to take the stage after local law enforcement had identified Crooks as suspicious.
Cheatle acknowledged that Crooks had been seen by local law enforcement before the shooting with a rangefinder, a small device resembling binoculars that hunters use to measure distance from a target. She said the Secret Service would never have taken Trump onto the stage if it had known there was an "actual threat."
Local law enforcement took a photograph of Crooks and shared it after seeing him acting suspiciously outside the security perimeter, but he wasn’t deemed to be a "threat" until seconds before he opened fire, she said.
"An individual with a backpack is not a threat," Cheatle said. "An individual with a rangefinder is not a threat."
When speaking directly to Cheatle, Langworthy expressed how he thought the nature of Crooks' intentions were suspicious to the nature of deeming him a threat well before the shooting took place.
"Your operational lapses, your resource management and poor judgment nearly resulted in the assassination of President Trump. The dereliction of duty here is just appalling. The fact that you haven't visited Butler is just maddening, to me. You're not taking this job seriously," Langworthy stated. "Many people here have called for your resignation, I've introduced a resolution here, into this body, that hopefully will get a vote this week calling on the President to fire you, ma'am. You have not done your job.
"You have put two black eyes on your agency, and you need to go."
When Republican Rep. Nancy Mace (R-South Carolina) suggested Cheatle begin drafting her resignation letter from the hearing room, Cheatle responded, "No, thank you." At one point, Mace used profanity as she accused Cheatle of lying and dodging questions, prompting calls for lawmakers to show "decorum."
"It has been 10 days since an assassination attempt on a former President of the United States. Regardless of party, there need to be answers," said Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-New York).
Cheatle said local enforcement officers were inside the building from which Crooks fired. But when asked why there were no agents on the roof or if the Secret Service used drones to monitor the area, Cheatle said she is still waiting for the investigation to play out, prompting groans and outbursts from members on the committee.
"Director Cheatle, because Donald Trump is alive, and thank God he is, you look incompetent," said Rep. Mike Turner, R-Ohio. "If he were killed you would look culpable."
Rep. Ro Khanna, one of the Democrats who joined the calls for Cheatle to resign, noted that the Secret Service director who presided over the agency when there was an attempted assassination of former Republican President Ronald Reagan later stepped down.
"The one thing we have to have in this country are agencies that transcend politics and have the confidence of independents, Democrats, Republicans, progressives and conservatives," Khanna said, adding that the Secret Service was no longer one of those agencies.
Trump was wounded in the ear, a former Pennsylvania fire chief was killed and two other attendees were injured after Crooks climbed atop the roof of a nearby building and opened fire with an AR-style rifle shortly after Trump started speaking at the rally.
Cheatle said the agency hopes to have its internal investigation completed in 60 days. Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas has separately appointed a bipartisan, independent panel to review the assassination attempt, while the department’s inspector general has opened three investigations.
The Secret Service has acknowledged it denied some requests by Trump's campaign for increased security at his events in the years before the assassination attempt. But Cheatle said Monday there were “no assets denied" for the Pennsylvania rally.
Authorities have been hunting for clues into what motivated Crooks but have not found any ideological bent that could help explain his actions. Investigators who searched his phone found photos of Trump, Biden and other senior government officials and found that he had looked up the dates for the Democratic National Conventional as well as Trump’s appearances. He also searched for information about major depressive order.
The attack on Trump was the most serious attempt to assassinate a president or presidential candidate since Reagan was shot in 1981. It was the latest in a series of security lapses by the agency that has drawn investigations and public scrutiny over the years.
Cheatle took over two years ago as head of the Secret Service's 7,800 special agents, uniformed officers and other staffers whose main purpose is protecting presidents, vice presidents, their families, former presidents and others. In announcing her appointment, Biden said Cheatle had served on his vice presidential detail and called her a “distinguished law enforcement professional with exceptional leadership skills” who had his “complete trust.”
Cheatle took the reins from James M. Murray as multiple congressional committees and an internal watchdog investigated missing text messages from when Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. The Secret Service says they were purged during a technology transition.